Slotkin backs Van Hollen's challenge to Schumer for Senate Democratic leader

RUKUS· · 7h ← 15d
Go Rogue

Fresh off winning at least seven Senate seats in the November 3 midterms, Democrats turned on their own leader: progressive groups including Indivisible called for Chuck Schumer to step aside as Senate Democratic leader, and petitions reached 100,000 signatures, yet no senator initially emerged to challenge him. Schumer said on the Wednesday after the election that he would be re-elected majority leader and claimed he had the votes to win unopposed.

Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen, who had said days earlier that he was not considering a run, changed course: after a Denver conference where he pitched a platform of lowering costs, ending the war in Iran, and holding AI companies accountable, he announced on November 12 that he would challenge Schumer, arguing the party needed a more populist direction. He ruled out a 2028 presidential run to pursue the post. Most sitting senators stayed with Schumer or stayed silent, but nearly all of the nine incoming Democrats said they would not support him, and unions and groups including the International Association of Machinists, MoveOn, and the Working Families Party lined up behind Van Hollen, threatening primary challenges against 2028 senators who did not.

The fight stayed tight-lipped: senators reported being besieged by calls, but a public whip count showed 15 senators backing Schumer and only five backing Van Hollen, with 34 taking no position, 28 votes needed to win on December 1. On November 19, Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin announced she would back Van Hollen, becoming the fifth caucus member to commit to him publicly. Schumer, asked about her endorsement outside the Capitol, said: 'We've got the votes.'

  1. Progressive groups including Indivisible called in the days after the November 2026 midterm elections for Chuck Schumer to step aside as Senate Democratic leader.

    No senator emerged to challenge Schumer, and none of the progressive groups calling for new leadership had a Senate Democrat volunteering for the post.

    Senators-elect Adam Hamilton of Kansas, Troy Jackson of Maine, and Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan said during their campaigns that they would not back Schumer for leader.

    Incoming senators Juliana Stratton, Peggy Flanagan, Chris Pappas, and James Talarico sidestepped questions about Schumer's leadership for months.

    Schumer said on the Wednesday after the election that he will be re-elected majority leader and that the focus should be on the American people, not him.

    Before the election, a compromise idea floated to let Schumer remain leader with the understanding that he would retire when his term ends in two years, potentially ceding his New York seat to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

    Schumer said the issue is not him but focusing on the American people and what they want.

    Indivisible said voters made it very clear they want a new generation of Democratic fighters and that it is time for Senate Democrats to choose new leadership.

    A victorious Democratic campaign consultant said no one loves Schumer but he is the only one who wants the job.

  2. Democrats flipped at least seven Senate seats in the November 3 midterms, including wins by Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, Troy Jackson over Susan Collins in Maine, Annie Andrews in South Carolina, Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota, and Adam Hamilton in Kansas.

    Petitions calling on Senate Democrats to replace Schumer as leader reached 100,000 signatures.

    El-Sayed declined to back Schumer and pointed to Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen as a potential replacement, having called Van Hollen the next Senate majority leader at a July 2026 campaign event.

    Schumer said he has the votes to win the Senate Democratic leadership election and does not expect to be challenged.

    Abdul El-Sayed said Van Hollen would make a great Senate Democratic leader, and that if Democrats have another option he will look at who is best placed to get action, get money out of politics, and pass Medicare for All.

    Peggy Flanagan said she is tremendously grateful for Schumer's leadership but it is time for new leadership in the Senate.

    Adam Hamilton said he is standing by his campaign promise not to support Schumer, that Democrats need a leader who unites people and builds bridges, and that the party needs younger leaders with fresh ideas.

    Troy Jackson said he is not going to support Schumer and has told him so.

    Juliana Stratton said during the primary that she would not be supporting Schumer.

    Elissa Slotkin said there needs to be new leadership in the White House, the House, and the Senate, on both sides of the aisle.

    Annie Andrews said it is time for generational change on both sides of the aisle.

    Schumer said the Democratic caucus is focused on moving forward and that if Democrats do not deliver, all of this will go away.

  3. Multiple Democratic senators expressed support for Schumer as leader in the days after the election.

    Van Hollen said he was not considering a run for majority leader.

    Van Hollen said at a Crooked Con event that Senate Democrats need a caucus discussion about their new responsibility and powers, and that nobody should get a blank check as leader without the caucus fully understanding where they are going.

    Van Hollen said senators should not commit to anyone for the leadership role without having a conversation and receiving specific commitments.

  4. Van Hollen pitched himself for Senate majority leader at a Democratic conference in Denver, naming lowering costs, ending the war in Iran, saving rural hospitals, getting money out of politics, holding AI companies accountable, and no public money for data centers as priorities.

    Van Hollen said at the Denver conference that he is running for Senate majority leader.

    Van Hollen called the United States' economic and political system rigged and said institutions that are not delivering for the American people should not be preserved.

  5. A movement to draft Van Hollen to challenge Schumer was underway, pushed by Indivisible co-executive director Ezra Levin, who had been in contact with Van Hollen as recently as the Sunday before.

    A person familiar with Van Hollen's thinking said he had received an outpouring of calls, was in active listening mode, and that the door was not shut.

    Van Hollen said in a live interview the week before that he was not looking to be the next Democratic leader and was weighing a 2028 presidential campaign, but declined to endorse Schumer.

    Van Hollen and Slotkin both declined to back Schumer at a post-election gathering in Washington.

    Ezra Levin said Van Hollen 'has not sought the position, but he has also not closed the door to the position,' and that with sufficient public demand he could enter the race and win.

    Van Hollen said, 'There should be no coronation of the next Democratic leader.'

    Abdul El-Sayed said of Van Hollen, 'I think he'd be an amazing Senate majority leader,' while acknowledging Van Hollen would first have to decide whether he wanted the job.

    Adam Hamilton said, 'Chuck Schumer is seen as a more divisive figure by many people, and I think we need somebody who's going to bring us together.'

    Mark Kelly said he planned to support Schumer while acknowledging that Senate Democrats needed to do things differently than they have before.

  6. Senators returned to Washington on November 9 with questions about their leadership after the election gave Democrats a new majority of as many as 56 seats, and Schumer's caucus election was expected in December 2026.

    Incoming Democratic senators visited the Capitol for the first time on November 9 and were split on how they will vote in the leadership elections.

    Van Hollen was considering a challenge to Schumer and was open to a run, according to a person familiar with his thinking.

    Kirsten Gillibrand said Schumer not only won the Senate back but 'cares deeply, and he understands politics well.'

    Abdul El-Sayed said he will support Van Hollen, whom he endorsed during his campaign, saying, 'I think he'd do a great job.'

    Sherrod Brown said he is supporting Schumer for leader but declined to elaborate.

    Peggy Flanagan said she is not ready to make any commitments on the leadership vote, saying, 'I think it's a moment where there are a lot of new voices, and making sure those voices are incorporated into the future of the Senate is really important.'

  7. The International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers wrote to Schumer on November 9 that this is the right moment for a new generation to lead Senate Democrats.

    Richard Blumenthal said he is open to new leadership if a challenger to Schumer emerges.

    Blumenthal said, 'But we need to have a conversation about leadership going forward, because we need new energy and ideas.'

  8. Van Hollen said he is in listening mode as Democrats float him as an alternative to Schumer, having gone from saying he is not interested in the leader post to saying he has not shut the door on it.

    Van Hollen said, 'What I've said from the very beginning is, we shouldn't have a coronation. I'm in listening mode and haven't shut the door.'

    Schumer said, 'I'm confident I will be elected majority leader. We have great unity in our caucus and I will be proud to lead it as majority leader.'

    Van Hollen said, 'We just had a big election. People spoke from all over the country, and Democratic senators need to make sure we have a plan to use our majority wisely on behalf of the American people.'

    David Karol of the University of Maryland said Van Hollen will not put his name forward unless assured of a significant number of votes, and that 'It's not going to hurt him if he runs against Schumer and loses, unless he is totally humiliated.'

  9. Bernie Sanders announced on November 10 that he will not support Schumer for Senate Democratic leader.

    Elissa Slotkin appeared with Sanders at a November 10 news conference and likewise called for a change of leadership without backing an alternative candidate.

    Senate Democrats will not elect their new leadership until December 2026.

    Bernie Sanders said, 'I personally have known Chuck Schumer for over 30 years, and I like Chuck. [There's] nobody who works harder than Chuck Schumer. But in my view, the time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be re-elected as the Democratic leader.'

    Slotkin said, 'I am not actively seeking this job. I am seeking change,' adding that she has long been consistent that Democrats need a new generation of leadership.

    Van Hollen said, 'We should not have a coronation. We should not support anybody for leader without a very clear plan, and as you know, there are many people who think change is required.'

    Schumer said, 'Our caucus is really united in focusing on bringing down costs, on ending the corruption, on ending the chaos, on ending the war. We have great unity in our caucus, and I'll be proud to lead it as majority leader.'

    Ruben Gallego said, 'When the manager takes you to the World Series, you give them another contract. Chuck and I have had our differences, but at the end of the day, it's time to unify.'

  10. Seven incoming Democratic senators had vowed not to support Schumer or called for new leadership, while a number of sitting senators made noncommittal statements.

    Van Hollen told MS NOW's Ali Vitali at a progressive event in Washington that he was 'in the process of calling my colleagues' about the leadership position.

    David Dayen wrote that hunger for a new leader does not mean an alternative exists, that Schumer is likely to stay in control, and that even if he loses, Van Hollen may derail Schumer's succession plan to hand the position to Brian Schatz.

  11. Van Hollen accused Schumer and the Senate Democratic campaign arm on November 10 of having 'sided with the crypto industry and AIPAC' to oppose more progressive candidates.

    John Fetterman said he will vote for Schumer, that Schumer 'helped recruit a great class,' and that he cannot imagine why anyone would vote for someone like Van Hollen 'with no record of doing anything.'

    Peggy Flanagan said, 'I have been very impressed by Senator Van Hollen's leadership.'

    Joseph Geevarghese, executive director of Our Revolution, said Van Hollen represents a bridge between the old guard and the new generation coming into office.

  12. Van Hollen was engaged in discussions with current and incoming Democratic senators ahead of the party's leadership election.

  13. Van Hollen announced on November 12 that he would challenge Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, arguing the party needs to take a more populist direction.

    Nearly all of the nine newly elected Senate Democrats taking office in January 2027 said they would not support Schumer as leader, and several sitting senators called for new leadership.

    Van Hollen said on MS NOW that more than 15 Senate Democrats had pledged support for his bid and that two sitting senators would not be there if Schumer had his way, because Schumer backed establishment candidates in the primaries.

    Schumer said in a statement on November 12 that he is proud of what Democrats have accomplished, calling 55 seats and counting an amazing result, and that he has the votes to continue serving as Democratic leader.

    Schumer said he will be elected Democratic leader because Senate Democrats are united on the issues.

    Van Hollen said the midterms were a call to reform a broken economic system rigged in favor of the very wealthy and a corrupt political system, not just a rejection of Donald Trump.

    Van Hollen said he would tackle the first 100 days of a Democratic-led Congress differently from Schumer and would not have gotten involved in Democratic primaries as leader.

  14. The closed-door, secret-ballot election for Senate Democratic leader will be held in early December 2026, the first contested race for the post in decades.

    Schumer worked one-on-one with Democratic senators on a 2027 agenda and opened discussion in November caucus meetings on a first-100-days plan including health care, tariff legislation, and efforts to stop the Iran war.

    A rift in the party opened in the spring of 2025 when Schumer sided with Republicans on a spending vote, and he later redeemed himself by leading Democrats through a government shutdown and the midterm wins.

    Most Democratic senators said they were supporting Schumer or were undecided, while Van Hollen's only declared backers were Abdul El-Sayed and Bernie Sanders.

    Schumer said in an interview, 'I'm going to win it.'

    Abdul El-Sayed wrote that the Democratic majority will need 'bold leadership' and that he called on Van Hollen to lead the caucus as a candidate back in April 2026 because 'he leads with courage and experience.'

    Bernie Sanders wrote that the American people want a Democratic Party that will stand up to powerful special interests, take on the billionaire class and fight for working families, and 'That is why I am supporting Senator Chris Van Hollen to lead Senate Democrats.'

    Angus King asked, 'Why would you fire the manager when you just won the World Series?' and wrote that Schumer is one of the principal architects of the most successful election in modern history.

    Catherine Cortez Masto said Schumer was key in securing a historic majority and that she will support him as Senate Democratic leader.

  15. Sens. Ruben Gallego, Angela Alsobrooks, and Kirsten Gillibrand publicly said they will support Schumer, and several other senators said privately that they intend to vote for him.

  16. Senate Democrats scheduled their closed-door leadership vote for December 1, with the party taking the Senate majority on January 4.

    Donors and organizations including MoveOn, Indivisible, and the Working Families Party planned to back Van Hollen and threatened primary challenges against Democratic senators up for reelection in 2028 who do not support him.

    Some senators refrained from publicly supporting Schumer to avoid pressure from activists urging his deposition, and other Democrats noted the contrast with Senate Republicans returning their leadership unchallenged after losing at least eight seats.

    Van Hollen said a little democracy in the Senate Democratic Caucus is a good thing, and that he is not deterred by Schumer's claim to have the votes because circumstances change.

    Fetterman said he does not understand why the leadership fight is a conversation.

  17. Van Hollen said the scale and scope of the Democrats' victory, 56 Senate Democratic seats, gives the party a mandate and the votes to do big things.

    Blumenthal said he is supporting Schumer but is excited by the new ideas and energy that new members are bringing to the Senate.

    Tim Kaine said the demand for change is very strong, but Schumer just led a historic effort to win, knows Donald Trump better than anybody else in the caucus, and Democrats have to accommodate the overwhelming desire for change.

    Schumer said he is totally confident he will win a majority of Democrats in their secret-ballot election.

    Van Hollen said Democrats cannot earn voters' trust with old leadership and need to move on to new leadership.

  18. Van Hollen outlined his differences with Schumer on MS NOW, pointing to his urgency to end the war in Iran rather than waiting until Democrats hold the majority.

    Van Hollen wrote, 'In this election, Americans called on us to unrig an economy rigged against working people & fueled by political corruption. To deliver, we need new leadership.'

    Van Hollen told MS NOW's Jen Psaki, 'I think that we heard loud and clear from the American people that they want to end the war in Iran and bring down prices. We should do it now. We shouldn't say we're going to wait till January.'

  19. Van Hollen's decision to run followed a listening tour with Senate Democrats and came after he had been 'kicking the tires' on entering the 2028 presidential conversation.

    Brian Schatz endorsed Schumer and said he will vote for him in the caucus election.

    Schatz said the caucus has the right to a conversation about the path ahead but has no time to waste and must move quickly to vote, unify, and get to work.

    Abdul El-Sayed said the American public rejected Trumpism in the midterms but Democrats have yet to earn their mandate, which will require bold leadership.

  20. The International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, a union of about 600,000 members, endorsed Van Hollen's bid on November 12, shortly after his announcement.

    Van Hollen disputed Schumer's claim to have locked down enough support to win, acknowledging he would be the underdog.

    IAM president Brian Bryant said, 'The IAM Union proudly supports Senator Chris Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader,' calling him a proven champion of working people, saying the contest is a fight of workers versus billionaires, and adding, 'Workers did their part on election night. Now it's Senate Democrats' turn.'

    Van Hollen told MS NOW he has the support of 'more than 10' of the 55 Democratic senators and senators-elect, including Bernie Sanders and Abdul El-Sayed.

    Van Hollen said people will now have to decide whether they want to vote for change or for the status quo.

  21. Senate Democrats were discussing whether to move the leadership election up to the week after November 13 to short-circuit the fight; otherwise the secret-ballot vote would take place on December 1.

    Schumer said on the night of November 12, 'I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader,' as Jacky Rosen of Nevada joined Catherine Cortez Masto and Angus King in making their support public.

    Van Hollen ruled out a 2028 presidential run on November 13 at the What's Next conference in Denver, saying, 'I am no longer pursuing that.'

    Van Hollen said, 'I think the American people want to see a little bit more democracy in the Senate Democratic Caucus.'

  22. Indivisible, which backs Van Hollen's bid, sent a memo to Capitol Hill Democrats arguing real accountability must include using the power of the purse, refusing to appropriate money for agencies or officials who do not comply with subpoenas.

    Greg Sargent predicted Van Hollen is unlikely to prevail against the deeply connected Schumer but could force a serious caucus discussion about how far Democrats will go in wielding congressional power to check Trump's lawlessness.

  23. A publicly tracked whip count found 14 of the 56 Senate Democrats publicly backing Schumer, 3 backing Van Hollen, 18 unclear, 15 with no public position, and 6 opposing Schumer without picking a candidate, with 29 votes needed to win.

  24. A count of public positions found 16 lawmakers behind Schumer, five explicitly backing Van Hollen, five wanting new leadership without naming Van Hollen, and 26 Democrats altogether veering away from Schumer.

    Mississippi Senator-elect Scott Colom refused to commit to Schumer after Schumer claimed credit for recruiting him to the race, saying the people of Mississippi recruited him instead.

    Scott Colom said, 'It's not accurate to say he recruited me, though, because the people of Mississippi recruited me,' adding, 'You think I was listening to somebody that lives in Brooklyn when I was deciding to run for United States Senate? No, I listened to the people of Mississippi.'

    Colom, asked whether he would support Schumer, said, 'I gotta know my options, and I'm not trying to be cute.'

    Colom said he does not think it is a good thing that Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries, in line to be House speaker, both live in the same borough of New York City.

  25. Retiring Minnesota Senator Tina Smith backed Van Hollen, though she cannot vote in the leadership election.

    Gillibrand said at a press conference that Schumer invested in the Mississippi Senate race a year before the election to boost Scott Colom, who flipped the seat.

    Fetterman said it is 'truly bizarre to me' that anyone would challenge Schumer, asked of Van Hollen, 'What's his record, other than yelling about anti-Israel stuff' and visiting Abrego Garcia in the El Salvador prison, and added, 'Why are we arguing amongst ourselves. We are now going to be 56 and 44.'

    Gillibrand said Democrats went into the elections 100% unified thanks to Schumer's decision making, and that takes vision, clarity of thought, and strategic leadership.

    Slotkin said Democrats need leadership that governs for the entirety of the caucus, for folks from blue, purple, and red states, and that 'You can't lead people if you can't lay out where you're going.'

    Peggy Flanagan wrote, 'Minnesotans are demanding change. Democrats need to deliver. That starts with new voices in our leadership,' saying she believes Van Hollen is the leader and fighter needed to bring real change.

    Tina Smith wrote in a post calling Van Hollen a close colleague and dear friend that Minnesota is tired of the status quo and ready for real change, and that starts with new leadership.

    Adam Hamilton said he means no disrespect for Schumer but that, at least where he lives in Kansas, Schumer is kind of a polarizing figure.

    Schumer said he and Van Hollen are 'friends' who 'talk frequently' and are 'united in lower costs, united in ending this damn war.'

  26. Anger at Schumer dates to March 2025, when he advanced a Republican-backed spending measure to avoid a government shutdown, triggering an explosion of anger from House Democrats and activist groups who saw it as a sign he was no longer fit to lead.

    Another wave of calls for Schumer to step down came later in 2025, when dissident Senate Democrats ended a record-long government shutdown without Republicans meeting their healthcare demands, in a deal widely believed to have his backing.

    By the 2026 midterm campaign, several Democratic candidates had made their opposition to Schumer prominent in their platforms.

    Van Hollen said at a press conference the day after announcing his challenge that he does not think you can close the trust deficit by simply returning to the status quo.

    Ezra Levin said Schumer 'has contributed to and led many important accomplishments that Indivisible is grateful for. But with our democracy on the line, he let us, the country and the Democratic party down,' and that Schumer should step aside as leader.

    MoveOn executive director Joel Payne said MoveOn's members are tired of politicians content with incrementalism and want bold, creative leadership, and 'We welcome and will support any potential Senate leader willing to meet the moment.'

  27. The Working Families Party wrote to Schumer urging him not to seek another term as Senate Democratic leader, endorsed Van Hollen, and called on Senate Democrats to back him.

    Jasmine Gripper, state director of the New York Working Families Party, said the voters who just elected a new Senate majority are asking for a new generation of leadership that will deliver on housing, healthcare, and childcare, and that Van Hollen is the right choice for this moment.

  28. Of the 13 incoming Democratic senators, only Sherrod Brown of Ohio had publicly pledged to support Schumer in the days after the election.

    Abdul El-Sayed defeated Haley Stevens, Schumer's preferred candidate, in Michigan's Senate primary, and Schumer called Stevens's endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers days before the election a 'despicable betrayal'; Schumer had also backed Angie Craig over Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota's primary.

    As of November 13, 14 senators had publicly pledged to support Schumer, roughly half the votes needed, while ten senators were on record opposing his bid.

    An Indivisible poll found 10 percent of respondents want Schumer to remain in leadership, and MoveOn cited figures showing 82 percent of its members want him replaced.

    The Democratic Socialists of America launched a 'Say No to Schumer' campaign, and Jeff Merkley, Our Revolution, and the Democratic Socialists of America backed Van Hollen.

    Van Hollen said the DSCC did not spend much in South Carolina or Mississippi until the very last minute.

    Ezra Levin said he is skeptical of Schumer's claim to have the votes, arguing that not seeing 29 senators en masse in a press release or press conference after Van Hollen announced means Schumer does not have them yet.

    Maurice Mitchell, national director of the Working Families Party, said the country wants change, immediate economic relief, accountability, and new leadership, and the group is supporting Van Hollen's bid.

  29. John Fetterman hinted in a November 14 Fox News interview that he could leave the Democratic Party if Van Hollen is elected Senate majority leader.

    Fetterman said it would be troubling if the caucus elected someone like Van Hollen, who has made his name being hostile to Israel, and that if you are going to be angry at any countries in the region, it should be Iran, Hezbollah, or Hamas as well.

  30. Van Hollen released a campaign ad for his Senate Democratic leader bid and allies began soliciting funds for the campaign.

    Joe Cirincione said Van Hollen is the leader Democrats need to meet this remarkable moment, that his uphill campaign is very winnable if supporters back him, and that Schumer is awash in donations from AIPAC and corporate PACs.

  31. Van Hollen said in Sunday interviews that the Senate Democratic leadership race is wide open and that he has about 15 votes.

    A Van Hollen victory would make him the first Democrat to oust his party's leader in Senate history.

    Van Hollen said he has a record of doing what the Democratic candidates on the campaign trail talked about, a populist message of unrigging an economic system stacked in favor of the very wealthy and fueled by political corruption.

  32. Dozens of protesters rallied outside Van Hollen's Baltimore office on November 14, urging Senate Democrats to elect him majority leader instead of Schumer.

    Ashley Esposito, an elected Baltimore school board member, said she supports Van Hollen because she did not want people to go to sleep after the election and wanted to maintain the momentum rather than look only to 2028.

  33. Elissa Slotkin announced she plans to support Van Hollen's leadership bid against Schumer.

    Slotkin said in a video she has been vocal for many years about the importance of a new generation of leadership in the Democratic Party, that Schumer is not best positioned to be the Democrats' next leader, and that she is encouraged that people like Van Hollen got into the race.

  34. Van Hollen endorsed a bipartisan plan by Jeff Merkley and Steve Daines to eliminate the 60-vote cloture threshold for nominations, amendments, and certain floor motions and to fast-track bipartisan legislation passed in committee, without addressing the legislative filibuster.

    Van Hollen said he favors reforming the legislative filibuster but that how and when to do it is a matter for the caucus to decide.

    Merkley said there cannot be a Senate where every movement feels like walking in mud up to the knees, or as one colleague put it like shoes stuck to tar, because it drives cynicism.

    Van Hollen said the effort is meant to 'breathe a little democracy' into the United States Senate and the Senate Democratic Caucus, and has called the legislative filibuster anti-democratic.

  35. Senate Democrats were set to meet in person for their weekly lunch on November 17, the first time since Van Hollen announced his challenge.

    Lawmakers showed little interest in expediting the leadership vote set for December 1.

    Lisa Blunt Rochester said the weekly lunch could feature a 'family conversation' about the face-off between Van Hollen and Schumer.

  36. A group affiliated with Schumer spent $1.2 million in Mississippi in the final stretch of the midterms, and Schumer recruited winning candidates including Roy Cooper in North Carolina and Sherrod Brown in Ohio.

    Andy Kim said Senate Democrats would talk the leadership question through as a caucus and had held one meeting so far as a full caucus.

    Tammy Baldwin said the Milwaukee Brewers just had a record season and next year is not the time to change management, comparing Schumer's leadership to the team's.

    Slotkin said, 'Senator Sanders and I disagree on some items, but we agree on the need for change.'

  37. National Nurses United, the largest union of nurses in the United States, endorsed Van Hollen for Senate majority leader.

    National Nurses United wrote that 'The Democratic Party must not squander the chance midterm voters have given it to tackle our nation in crisis,' that nurses and working people demand new Senate leadership, and that 'Sen. Van Hollen is the best person for the job.'

  38. Interviews with about a dozen Democratic senators and senior aides found little appetite for moving up the December 1 election, with Jon Ossoff saying he would oppose expediting it before the party has had a full process.

    Mazie Hirono publicly backed Schumer on November 16.

    Schumer said he has gathered the 28 or 29 votes needed to win, though only about 15 senators had publicly backed him, and several other senators privately said they will support him.

    Van Hollen built a public campaign with a 'Chris for Leader' website and Sunday talk show interviews, criticizing Schumer's opposition to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal that Trump later tore up.

    The public whip count in the leadership race largely stagnated after the initial round of endorsements following Van Hollen's entry.

    Hirono said, 'I have a long history with Chuck.'

    John Hickenlooper made a coin-toss motion when asked which candidate he supports and questioned why some Democrats are trying to ditch Schumer after the party flipped nine seats.

    Tim Kaine said he is undecided, but Schumer delivered an amazing win, knows Donald Trump, and no one not on the ballot worked harder for the victory.

    Martin Heinrich said he is in listening mode: 'I'm going to hear them both out, and I want to hear from the freshman class as well.'

    Van Hollen said he believes he has momentum in his supporter count and is really worried Democrats might blow what could be a huge opportunity to deliver.

  39. Harry Enten joked that Democrats' reaction to Fetterman's threat to leave the party would be 'good riddance,' mocking the idea that losing his vote would matter.

    John Berman suggested that with a larger Senate majority, Democrats no longer necessarily need Fetterman's vote as much as they once did.

  40. Van Hollen, joined by a growing number of Senate Democrats including Bernie Sanders, Tammy Duckworth, and Michael Bennet, backed a rider barring any appropriated money from being put toward hostilities in Iran.

    Van Hollen said, 'I think we need to use all our powers right now to end this illegal war against Iran,' that 'that means not one penny more,' and that this is not the current majority leader's position.

    David Dayen wrote that the most careful whip count shows the outcome is still in doubt, and that Van Hollen has made Iran funding the front of the debate, representing the leadership fight itself: action versus caution.

  41. Schumer's undecided 2028 Senate reelection plans loomed over his leadership bid; he declined to discuss his political future, saying his 'total focus' is on 2027.

    Van Hollen said he would have more public backers if senators were not worried about 'retaliation' from Schumer, who has not criticized him publicly.

    John Hickenlooper said maybe Schumer stays as the leader but there are other teams, asking whether there are different roles other people could do to help.

    Many Democratic senators doubt Schumer will seek reelection in 2028 and are skeptical he could survive a primary challenge from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or another candidate on his left.

    Schumer's backers, public and private, are frustrated that Van Hollen's bid is sowing disarray in the caucus after the Democrats' decisive midterm wins.

  42. Gavin Newsom chastised Schumer for 'capitulating' to the Republicans during the 2025 government shutdown and voting to reopen the government without securing concessions in return.

  43. A Progressive Change Campaign Committee whip count listed 15 senators as firm for Schumer with Tim Kaine presumed for Schumer, 15 as publicly uncommitted, 14 as debate/open, five unwilling to vote for Schumer but not yet committed to Van Hollen, and five firm for Van Hollen: Sanders, Merkley, El-Sayed, Flanagan, and Van Hollen himself.

    A Van Hollen supporter said the Georgia senators Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock may influence colleagues, that a united front from the incoming class would make it 'close to game over,' and that James Talarico is the new member to watch most closely.

    An anonymous Schumer ally said Van Hollen doesn't think he's going to win and is trying to get some 'meat on the bone' for the causes that the new members want.

    Van Hollen said in a campaign ad that Americans voted against 'a politics that is too timid to stand up' and that 'We have become a party that too often trims its sails. Too cautious, too rudderless. Too attached to poll-washed, pundit-rinsed, and donor-dried messages.'

    Slotkin said she is a 'no' until she sees a plan for governance, and that whoever wants to run the caucus should come forward with a plan for the first 100 days to put money in people's pockets and communicate differently.

    Murshed Zaheed, a former senior leadership aide to Harry Reid, said he cannot recall more than double-digit members of an incoming caucus being eager to defect from their Senate leader, crediting Van Hollen's April 2025 El Salvador trip to meet Kilmar Abrego Garcia as 'the first visible opposition to Trump.'

  44. Polling analysis found Schumer's net favorability among Democratic voters had fallen 56 points to minus nine, the worst on record in more than 40 years of polling, with 83 percent of Democrats saying their leaders need to fight more.

    A prediction market gave Schumer a 90 percent chance of being the next Democratic Senate leader, up from 49 percent two months earlier.

    Senators were lobbying Schumer for committee gavels and their choice of committees, giving him extensive face time with members who want something from him.

    Harry Enten predicted Schumer will be the next Democratic Senate leader even if Democratic voters back home do not want that.

    Mississippi's newly elected Democratic senator said the Democratic Party is too concentrated in urban areas and both new majority leaders live in the same borough, and that the party needs leadership that understands rural America.

    James Talarico said the American people cannot wait two years for change, and that if Trump wants the same plaques, portraits, and busts as Lyndon B. Johnson, Democrats should help make his final two years the most productive of any presidency in American history.

  45. Allies of Schumer told reporters he had more than 40 votes already locked down, well above the 28 or 29 he needs depending on the Alaska outcome.

    A reliable source said Angela Alsobrooks is privately saying she backs Schumer because he got to her first.

    Schumer's critics noted he backed centrists who faltered in Maine and Michigan and failed to direct financing to Louisiana and Florida, where Democrats lost by small margins.

    David Corn said Van Hollen is correct that he is the underdog, but Schumer is likely to win the majority leader vote though anything is possible.

  46. Schumer said his race against Van Hollen is effectively over, and his allies predicted he will win more than 40 votes in the December 1 election.

    Only four Democrats voting in the December 1 election had publicly announced support for Van Hollen.

  47. On a private Saturday conference call, Senator-elect Annie Andrews raised the leadership fight and expressed dismay that it was threatening to overshadow the party's victory.

    Most Democratic senators declined to comment after their weekly caucus luncheon, where the leadership fight was not discussed and senators instead spoke about funding for the Iran war.

    Senators and their aides acknowledged their offices have been besieged by calls about the leadership election.

    Some Schumer backers privately hope he does not misread their support as a signal he can continue indefinitely, and some suggest he announce the coming two years would be his last term, as Nancy Pelosi did in 2018, but his allies view that as a drastic move that would create a lame-duck aura.

    Multiple Democrats said Schumer needs to step back as the party's primary spokesman, let the freshman class occupy the limelight, and expand the leadership team to bring in new voices; allies said he seems open to the suggestions.

    Andrews said on the call that it is as if a cardiothoracic surgeon and a trauma surgeon stood outside a trauma bay arguing over who would take the lead while a patient bled out, when what is needed is someone to stop the bleeding.

    Kaine said he is getting a lot of calls and people are frustrated when he tells them he saves his conversations about the leadership fight for members of the caucus.

    Hickenlooper said, 'Leave it to the Democrats': the party flipped nine seats and the person who actually helped put it all together now faces a revolt.

    Abdul El-Sayed said at an Atlantic event that it is 'healthy' for Democrats to hold their leadership discussions in public.

    Schumer said at a news conference, 'I have the votes' to continue in his post.

  48. Abdul El-Sayed said his support for Van Hollen is not about being against anyone and he likes Schumer personally, but that if the choice were between Fetterman and Schumer he would go with Schumer, and he is interested in working with whoever will get money out of politics, put money in pockets, and pass Medicare for All.

  49. Bernie Sanders said he likes Schumer but that Schumer has not shown the sense of urgency needed to address the crisis facing working families, and that Democrats need the guts to take on the big money in the Democratic Party.

    Sanders said he is not formally whipping votes for Van Hollen but is doing his best on his behalf.

  50. Democrats used Van Hollen's challenge to pressure Schumer to cede more control over the 2027 agenda and shift power away from the majority leader's office, with senators tiring of his grip on caucus lunches and the Democratic agenda.

    Schumer declined to address Van Hollen's demand that the Democratic leader stay neutral in Democratic primaries and made no public concessions, saying only that he has the votes.

    Democratic sources said some senators are ready to vote for Schumer but want an indication he will step down from leadership at the end of this Congress, which he has not promised and appears reluctant to give.

    An anonymous Democratic senator called Schumer a 'lame duck,' saying 'everyone knows that he's a lame duck.'

    Tammy Duckworth said the caucus needs more input from rank-and-file senators who have been fighting in the trenches and from the freshman senators who just won, and should look at the caucus rules and how it goes about its business.

    Martin Heinrich said 'we do better work when committees are empowered,' and that he has pitched giving committees more authority in the next Congress to both candidates.

    A senior Democratic aide predicted there will be 'less of Chuck Schumer' in 2027.

  51. A Data for Progress survey found 56 percent of Democratic-leaning voters favor replacing Schumer as Senate Democratic leader, while 31 percent say he should continue.

    Van Hollen said, 'We wouldn't be in this spot if Trump had not torn up the JCPOA. But we wouldn't even have a JCPOA if the vote of the current leader had prevailed.'

    Mark Schmitt of New America said people are overemphasizing perceived ideological differences between Schumer and Van Hollen, since individual senators rather than the party leader set the Senate's ideological tone.

    Jim Kessler of Third Way, a former Schumer staffer, said that as majority leader Van Hollen would be forced to take actions that anger his base, and that no matter what he says in the campaign he would have to succumb to those impulses or be booted out.

    Van Hollen, Sanders, Michael Bennet, and Tammy Duckworth said in a statement, 'When we vote on appropriations, we intend to fund the government and stop funds for this war. It is what the American people demand, and what they deserve.'

  52. A whip count found 16 Senate Democrats backing Schumer, five backing Van Hollen, four opposing Schumer without endorsing his rival, and 30 uncommitted; only senators in the next Congress can vote, and Amy Klobuchar's election as Minnesota governor leaves 55 voting Democrats because she will not name her successor until January.

    Angela Alsobrooks said Schumer asked her and other caucus members for support before she knew Van Hollen was running, and that she offered him her commitment and keeps her word.

    Four senators who struck the 2025 deal with Republicans to end the government shutdown are backing Schumer, along with Democrats with more progressive voting records such as Richard Blumenthal and Tammy Baldwin.

    Jeff Merkley wrote that Americans are desperate to restore government by and for the people, not the privileged and powerful, and the party needs leadership that carries that responsibility in heart and gut.

    Chris Coons wrote that the American people showed how much they want change and that Democrats need a caucus leadership team that shows they hear them.

    Juliana Stratton said Van Hollen brings an interesting perspective, that she is continuing conversations with him and her future colleagues, and that she believes it is time for new leadership.

    Josh Turek said he met briefly with both candidates, likes both, and will meet again to learn their plans on water, cancer rates, farming, rural communities, health care, and who will put forward the most robust anti-corruption agenda.

    Ron Wyden said his vote will go to whoever best helps him deliver Medicare for All, a billionaire income tax to save Social Security, and an end to the Trump tariffs.

    Peter Welch said Democrats need change and have an opportunity, and the caucus should hear what the candidates have to say.

    Bernie Sanders wrote in an op-ed that the contest is not a personality contest but a debate about the Democratic Party's future, whether it remains a top-down party dominated by billionaire contributors or becomes a grassroots party of working families.

    Jacky Rosen wrote that Schumer did the work to deliver what will soon be a 56-seat Senate majority against all odds and has the experience and the fight to continue leading the caucus.

    Angela Alsobrooks's commitment to Schumer came before Van Hollen entered the race, and she said she keeps her word.

  53. Van Hollen said setting guardrails around artificial intelligence will be a top priority if he wins the leadership race, that AI companies should be fully liable for any harm they cause, that he would prioritize policies targeting private equity in youth sports, health care, and small business acquisitions, and that lawmakers should go after surveillance pricing.

  54. Van Hollen signaled support for the American Innovation and Competition Online Act, the bipartisan Big Tech antitrust bill that stalled in 2022, saying it is 'definitely the kind of bill that needs to come up for a vote' and would be expedited under Merkley's proposal.

  55. At a Capitol news conference on November 19, Van Hollen laid out an AI agenda of mandatory independent evaluations of AI systems, greater corporate liability for harm, and protections against threats to employment, privacy, and cybersecurity, and raised the possibility of banning AI systems capable of recursively improving themselves.

    Van Hollen endorsed the Merkley-Daines proposal to expedite bipartisan legislation out of Senate committees, arguing there has been way too much centralization of power in the Senate.

    Schumer warned in a Senate floor speech on November 18 that insufficient federal action on artificial intelligence could expose the country to serious technological disruptions.

    Critics of Schumer noted that one of his daughters recently joined OpenAI to oversee policy and partnerships in the Northeast and that another has worked at Meta.

    Van Hollen said the Senate moves like a glacier compared to the rushing stream of AI risks and the chamber needs 'a Senate that's equal to the AI age,' and that regulating AI would face 'an army of lobbyists' so 'You have to turn the page to get that done.'

    Schumer said the country must ensure the safe development and deployment of AI or it will see more outages and, as he put it, possibly even catastrophic events going forward.

  56. Slotkin's endorsement made her the third returning senator to back Van Hollen, bringing his public supporters to six, while more than a dozen senators back Schumer.

    Schumer, asked outside the Capitol about Slotkin's announcement, said, 'We've got the votes.'

    Slotkin said in her video that the American public want a new generation and they want big and bold ideas, that the country cannot afford 'small nibbling at the edges,' and that Nancy Pelosi is an example from the House of how to hand off successfully.

    Van Hollen wrote in response to the endorsement that the American people spoke and the United States Senate needs new leadership.

    Van Hollen said there is 'an element of concern about political retaliation' among his colleagues, downplaying his lower public vote count.

  57. Slotkin announced on November 19 that she will back Van Hollen, becoming the fifth Senate Democratic caucus member to announce a vote for him, after previously saying any candidate needed to present a vision for the party's first 100 days in power.

    Van Hollen says he has around 15 public and private commitments, short of the 28 needed in addition to his own vote.

    Slotkin said the American public spoke loud and clear about wanting a new generation of leadership, 'Not marginal change. Not small nibbling at the edges.'

  58. Senator-elect Adam Hamilton said he will keep his campaign promise not to vote for Schumer for majority leader but would not yet say whom he will back because the ballot is secret.

    John Hickenlooper posted a letter to Schumer and Van Hollen saying his vote is up for grabs and that both need to be serious about artificial intelligence.

    Hamilton said Schumer has done amazing things and he means no offense, but he is looking for someone who brings people together, which many Kansans do not feel Schumer does.

    Van Hollen said to stay tuned because momentum is growing for his reform effort, and that Democrats cannot go back to business as usual and the status quo if they are to deliver the big things American voters voted for.

  59. The Hill's whip list counted 15 senators for Schumer and five for Van Hollen, with 34 Democratic senators not publicly taking a position and 28 votes needed to win the caucus election on December 1.

    Abdul El-Sayed had backed Van Hollen as his 'number one pick for majority leader' during his Senate campaign, before Van Hollen launched his candidacy.

    Van Hollen said on the MeidasTouch Podcast that he is the underdog because the incumbent has the powers of incumbency, but that the race is wide open with many senators who have not declared where they stand.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.