Germany's Pistorius apologizes to Colby for calling Ukraine strike criticism stupid
Meinung: Die Lage am Morgen - Pistorius patzt, Hilfen für die Ukraine, AfD auf Kurssuche, Trump lobt Miller
»Ziemlich dumme Sache«: Pistorius entschuldigt sich bei US-Verteidigungsstaatssekretär Colby für Wortwahl
Pentagon strategist ‘walked out of Nato talks after criticising Ukraine’
Pentagon official’s stunning exit before secret war briefing leaves allies fearful: report
Pentagon strategist ‘walked out of Nato talks after criticising Ukraine’
Europe Backs Ukraine’s Deep Strikes Amid US Criticism
Germany, UK push back after US criticizes Ukraine's deep strikes into Russia
A dispute over Ukraine's long-range strikes inside Russia flared at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels on November 17, 2026. US Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby told allies that Ukraine's deep strikes had not been effective in ending the war or blunting Russian advances on the front line. He also warned that Ukrainian attacks on commercial infrastructure in Russia, including warehouses of the online retailer Wildberries, could reinforce Russian public support for the war and increase the Kremlin's willingness to escalate. Ukraine alleges Wildberries supplies equipment and technical components used by the Russian military, which the retailer denies.
Germany and Britain rejected the US criticism the same day. The disagreement surfaced during talks among Ukraine's military supporters over further weapons deliveries, particularly air defense systems, as Russia continues targeting Ukrainian cities and critical infrastructure. Ukraine has increasingly used domestically developed long-range drones and missiles against Russian oil refineries, military installations, and logistics infrastructure to disrupt supplies to Russian forces and cut revenue funding the war; its strikes had hit 28 Russian oil refineries and collapsed part of the Kerch Bridge.
Colby left the meeting immediately after his remarks, before Ukrainian Defense Minister Yevhenii Khmara could present a classified battlefield briefing, and US Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker represented Washington for the rest of the session. Speaking to reporters at NATO headquarters at around 5pm before flying out, Colby drew a sharp German response: Defense Minister Boris Pistorius called it a 'pretty dumb thing' to criticize Ukrainian attacks without criticizing Russian ones.
On the evening of November 18 Pistorius telephoned Colby and apologized for the remark.
At a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels on November 17, 2026, US Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby said Ukraine's deep strikes inside Russia had not been effective in ending the war or blunting Russian advances on the front line.
Colby warned that Ukrainian attacks on commercial infrastructure in Russia, including warehouses of the online retailer Wildberries, could reinforce Russian public support for the war and increase the Kremlin's willingness to escalate.
Ukraine has targeted Wildberries facilities, alleging the retailer supplies equipment and technical components used by the Russian military, which Wildberries denies.
Germany and Britain rejected the US criticism of Ukraine's long-range strikes inside Russia on November 17, 2026.
The disagreement emerged during talks among Ukraine's military supporters over additional weapons deliveries, particularly air defense systems, as Russia continues targeting Ukrainian cities and critical infrastructure.
Ukraine has increasingly used domestically developed long-range drones and missiles to strike Russian oil refineries, military installations, and logistics infrastructure to disrupt supplies to Russian forces and cut revenue funding the war.
Elbridge Colby said, "While the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to inflict pain on the Russian population, our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line."
Colby said, "This is not to say that Ukraine should be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back."
Colby maintained that Western military assistance should prioritize Ukraine's ability to defend its front lines, including equipment and medium-range strike capabilities to disrupt Russian logistics and slow advancing forces.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius said, "Instead of criticizing that, we should rather criticize and talk about the terroristic strikes every night and every day on ... energy, water, and heating infrastructure in Ukraine."
Pistorius called criticism of Ukrainian strikes on legitimate military targets inside Russia "quite a stupid thing."
British Defense Secretary Wes Streeting defended Ukraine's long-range operations, saying they had helped weaken Russia's military capabilities, buy time, and save lives.
Ukraine's Defense Minister Yevhen Khmara said Ukraine will more than triple its deep-strike capabilities in 2027 by expanding its arsenal of long-range drones and improving their effectiveness against targets inside Russia.
Khmara warned Moscow that Ukraine will respond to Russian strikes with "two or three times greater" force or more.
Wes Streeting said it is not for Ukraine's partners to tell Ukraine how to fight its war.
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte defended Ukraine's efforts to disable Russia's war machine.
Colby said strikes on Russia's war machinery can weaken its offensive capabilities, but Washington favors frontline defense and medium-range strikes against military logistics.
Colby walked out of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting immediately after delivering his remarks, departing before Ukrainian Defense Minister Yevhenii Khmara could present a classified battlefield briefing.
US Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker represented Washington for the remainder of the session after Colby left as soon as the media departed.
Colby addressed reporters in the atrium of NATO headquarters in Brussels at around 5pm local time before departing for the airport to catch a flight.
Ukrainian deep strikes had hit 28 Russian oil refineries and collapsed part of the Kerch Bridge in the campaign Colby criticized.
»Ziemlich dumme Sache«: Pistorius entschuldigt sich bei US-Verteidigungsstaatssekretär Colby für Wortwahl
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius telephoned Elbridge Colby on the evening of November 18 and apologized for saying it was a 'pretty dumb thing' to criticize Ukrainian attacks without criticizing Russian ones.
Pistorius said he found his word choice not really appropriate in hindsight, attributing it to an unlucky formulation as a non-native speaker at an English-language press conference.
Pistorius said he apologized for the word choice but made clear, as he says Colby sees the same way, that the two hold different views on the matter.
Pistorius said he does not expect the episode to strain German-American defense cooperation.
Pistorius defended German support for the development and production of Ukrainian long-range weapons.
Pistorius said the decision on how Ukrainian long-range weapons are used belongs to Ukraine itself.
Pistorius said the Ukrainian attacks on targets in Russia are targeted and strategic and not directed against the civilian population.
Meinung: Die Lage am Morgen - Pistorius patzt, Hilfen für die Ukraine, AfD auf Kurssuche, Trump lobt Miller
Commentator Marina Kormbaki judged that Boris Pistorius twice learned in the week how advisable it is to weigh one's words in international politics, especially on war and peace.
Kormbaki read Pistorius's apology as showing that he does not want to fall out with the Americans again.
Kormbaki judged that Pistorius's plain language becomes his greatest weakness when he will not stand by what he said, turning the plain talker into a master of backpedaling.
