Justice Department shifts criminal probe toward Peltola campaign and Democratic operatives

RUKUS· · 30h ← 5d
Go Rogue

The Justice Department is criminally investigating an alleged scheme to run a similarly named candidate against Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska.

Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Sullivan and was declared the winner, giving her party a 56-44 Senate edge.

The department dropped its certification lawsuit after a judge dismissed it; the probe now targets Peltola's campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and consultants.

Peltola has denied the allegations, saying she was not aware of any effort to recruit the similarly named candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan.

Dozens of FBI agents, hundreds of subpoenas, target letters, and a monthly federal grand jury have been reported in the investigation.

Democrats call the probe politically motivated, and Alaska authorities are conducting their own inquiry.

  1. With about 97% of the vote counted, Peltola led with 140,637 votes, 559 more than her three opponents combined.

    At President Donald Trump's direction, his administration sued to prevent Alaska from certifying a Peltola victory, claiming the similarly named candidate could confuse voters.

    A federal judge dismissed the lawsuit, and the Justice Department appealed to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

    Alaska State Sen. Bill Wielechowski said, 'In Alaska, we don't like when the federal government tells us how to do things, particularly how to run our lives and run our elections.'

    President Donald Trump stepped up social media posts about the race and told reporters the Alaska Senate race was a 'disgrace'.

    Former Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer and UCLA Law scholars warned the Ninth Circuit in briefs that allowing federal interference with Alaska's certification would set a dangerous precedent for future elections.

  2. Mary Peltola was declared the winner of Alaska's Senate race, giving Democrats a 56-44 edge in the Senate.

    A criminal grand jury investigation remains underway into whether Peltola campaign staffers or others recruited the same-named spoiler candidate to confuse voters.

    Prosecutors sent target letters and document preservation warnings to people suspected of recruiting Dan J. Sullivan, including election lawyer Marc Elias.

    U.S. Attorney Michael J. Heyman announced the grand jury probe five days before Election Day, an unusual public disclosure.

    The 9th Circuit will not finish collecting arguments until January 11, after Peltola is slated to take office, and the Justice Department has not asked to speed the case.

    Spoiler candidate Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher, drew fewer than 5,000 votes, less than half of Peltola's winning margin of more than 12,000.

    Mary Peltola denied allegations that her staffers or others recruited a spoiler candidate to confuse voters.

    Attorney General Todd Blanche told reporters, 'The priority of investigating a criminal potential fraud doesn't stop because of the election, no matter who wins or loses.'

    Asked whether the Justice Department would drop its cases if Peltola pulled ahead, Attorney General Todd Blanche said, 'No. That investigation remains where it was, which means I'm not going to talk about it.'

    Election lawyer Marc Elias, whose firm represented Peltola's campaign, brushed aside the target letters as the Justice Department's latest attempt to target President Donald Trump's political enemies.

    Dan J. Sullivan, the retired teacher whose Senate candidacy sparked the dispute, repeatedly insisted that his campaign was legitimate.

    UCLA election law scholar Richard L. Hasen wrote, 'This Court should send a swift and clear message to the federal government and the country that the State of Alaska, and Alaska alone, has the right to certify the winner of its elections.'

    Democrats blasted both the civil suit and the criminal grand jury probe as an unprecedented bid to tip the election.

  3. The Justice Department dropped its lawsuit to block certification, telling an appeals court the case is moot because ballots for the two Sullivans can no longer be separated.

    In a court filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward said, 'The case is now moot,' adding, 'There is, accordingly, no need to delve into standing or the merits of the United States' claims.'

  4. At least 50 FBI agents and more than a dozen Justice Department lawyers were reported working on the investigation, with a federal grand jury meeting monthly in Alaska.

    Nearly 100 letters informing parties to preserve records were sent, and five field offices were reported to be involved in the investigation.

    Asked whether there is any way Mary Peltola will not take office in January 2027, Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy said, 'I don't have the answer to that question, seriously. We're investigating. All I can tell you is, we'll see where that leads. It's going to take a little bit of time.'

    Alaska Republican leaders are conducting their own investigation of the Senate election, and the Alaska Bureau of Investigation said it continues to investigate election-related allegations.

  5. The Justice Department's criminal investigation has shifted away from candidate Daniel J. Sullivan toward Mary Peltola's campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and outside consultants.

    Amid public pressure from President Donald Trump, Justice Department officials weighed whether a charge could be brought against the spoiler candidate nicknamed 'Decoy Dan'.

    Democrats argued that recruiting spoiler candidates is a common and legal strategy and called the investigation politically motivated.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.