Trump judicial nominee Sullivan's wife has represented Elon Musk's companies
Donald Trump’s New and Corrupt Gift to Elon Musk
Trump Judge Nominee Won’t Say If He Can Run for President a Third Time
Trump Nominee Blanks On Constitutional Basics — And Things Only Get Worse From There
Trump’s latest judicial nominee gets rightfully skewered
Trump Judicial Nom. Immediately Fails Grim Live Lesson on Constitution
'Embarrassing' Trump judicial nominee ridiculed after 'train wreck' hearing meltdown
President Donald Trump nominated Texas Supreme Court Justice James P. Sullivan to a lifetime seat on the federal district court for the Western District of Texas.
At his Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on 18 November 2026, Sullivan could not recall the 22nd Amendment until Senator Chris Coons prompted him.
Sullivan declined to say whether Trump can run for a third term in 2028, citing the American Bar Association's Canon 5 and calling the question political debate.
Sullivan lost his reelection bid for justice of the Texas Supreme Court on 3 November 2026, days before senators questioned him.
Sullivan did not respond when Senator Richard Blumenthal asked him and other nominees whether the Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021.
A later report noted Sullivan's disclosure that his wife has represented Elon Musk and Tesla, and that his district covers Musk's Austin-area interests.
Republican Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana challenged Sullivan's interpretation of the Eighth Amendment's prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment at the hearing.
Senator John Kennedy told Sullivan 'You're talking in circles, judge' as Sullivan struggled to explain his originalist philosophy.
Activist Jim Stewartson called Sullivan's hearing performance 'one of the most embarrassing things I've ever seen'.
Education expert Rose Benson wrote that 'the only qualification Trump used for appointing judges is whether they let him run again'.
Aaron Rupar shared a clip of Kennedy telling Sullivan 'You're talking in circles', writing that Sullivan is such a trainwreck that even the Republican senator is clowning him.
At his confirmation hearing on 18 November 2026, Sullivan struggled to recall the 22nd Amendment until Senator Chris Coons prompted him with the words 'No person shall be elected'.
Sullivan said President Donald Trump had been certified as the winner of the 2016 and 2024 presidential elections.
Sullivan declined to say whether Trump is eligible to run for president again in 2028, citing Canon 5 of the American Bar Association's Code of Judicial Conduct and calling the question a subject of ongoing political debate.
Senator Chris Coons called Sullivan's answer very disappointing and said the 22nd Amendment is 'bracingly clear', with the question unresolved only in President Trump's mind.
Journalist Aaron Rupar wrote on social media that Sullivan revealed he does not know what the 22nd Amendment says and refused to say it would be illegal for Trump to serve a third term.
Sullivan told Senator Dick Durbin that he was on the ballot on 3 November 2026 for justice of the Supreme Court of Texas and realized that evening that he had lost.
The Daily Kos commentary called the exchange with Coons wild and urged the Senate to block Sullivan's nomination.
Sullivan said he would look to the text of the 22nd Amendment and its original public meaning, and recalled that the amendment came in the wake of Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
Senator Richard Blumenthal asked Sullivan and other judicial nominees to recall the events of January 6, 2021, and none of the nominees responded.
Senator Richard Blumenthal said 'Nobody? It's a sad day' after Sullivan and the other nominees would not say the Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021.
Alithea Sullivan, the nominee's wife, has represented Elon Musk and the board of Tesla in the Western District of Texas, and Musk's Twitter in its lawsuit against Media Matters.
In a disclosure to the Senate Judiciary Committee, James Sullivan stated that his wife Alithea is a partner at the law firm Stone Hilton PLLC.
If confirmed, Sullivan would be a federal judge in the Western District of Texas, which covers the Austin area where Elon Musk and some of his businesses are based.
Writer Andrew Perez argued that Sullivan could be Elon Musk's ace in the hole, calling Stone Hilton PLLC Musk's go-to law firm and finding Sullivan's deference to Trump concerning.
