Todd Blanche's office ordered criminal probe of Jim Justice's Southern Coal shut down

RUKUS· · 31h ← 2d
Go Rogue

The Justice Department in February 2026 ordered prosecutors to withdraw subpoenas and close a criminal investigation of Southern Coal, the coal company owned by Sen. Jim Justice of West Virginia and run largely by his son.

Prosecutors opened the probe in February 2025 after two former employees said Southern Coal or its sister companies falsified water pollution test results.

A 2016 settlement let Southern Coal avoid up to $880 million in fines for more than 23,000 alleged pollution violations by paying a $900,000 fine and upgrading pollution controls.

Residents of Wyoming County, West Virginia, say they depended on the probe to learn whether local drinking water is contaminated by mining operations.

  1. In February 2026, after attorney James McDonald contacted Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche's office to object, Blanche's deputies ordered Environment and Natural Resources Division supervisors to withdraw the subpoenas and shut down the Southern Coal criminal probe.

    Southern Coal went to court to block the subpoena for its company records, claiming they were protected by attorney-client privilege, while prosecutors awaited the judge's decision.

    Later in 2025, the division's environmental crimes section sent subpoenas for internal Southern Coal records approved by Assistant Attorney General Stanley Woodward, then a second set of subpoenas for the lab test results.

    In February 2025, Justice Department prosecutors opened a criminal investigation of Southern Coal, concerned its officials might be intentionally violating the law and the company's 2016 settlement with the department.

    In late 2024, prosecutors learned of two former employees who said Southern Coal or its sister companies had falsified water test results meant to detect violations of pollution limits.

    In the six years before the probe, the Justice Department went to court to force Southern Coal to comply with the 2016 settlement, and a federal appellate court rejected the company's argument that letting pollution permits expire let it ignore the law.

    Sen. Jim Justice disputed that any water tests were falsified, saying, 'I think every bit of that is bogus as bogus can be. There is no chance, no chance whatsoever, that we've been involved in anything like that'.

    The Justice Department said in an email that it 'did not shutter any investigation'.

    Steven Ruby, a lawyer for Sen. Jim Justice's family businesses, said in a statement that the allegations came from disgruntled former employees and that after the companies gave the Justice Department refuting evidence it 'found no basis to continue an investigation'.

    Representatives for Southern Coal and the Justice Department both said there was not sufficient evidence to pursue a criminal probe.

    An attorney for the Justice family said in a statement that the family had a 'nearly 20-year professional relationship' with Sullivan & Cromwell 'that has nothing to do with President Trump'.

    A Justice Department spokesperson said in a statement, 'We take seriously our duty to ensure all Americans have clean air and water. We work with investigating agencies to follow the facts of any case and ensure any violations are appropriately addressed'.

    Former Justice Department officials said the sudden intervention of top appointees to withdraw subpoenas and close the case deviates dramatically from the department's norms.

    Rick Mountcastle, a former U.S. attorney whose office helped bring the civil lawsuit against Southern Coal, called the shutdown of the case 'unheard of' and 'really troubling'.

    Kate Waldeck said the Justice Department owed the people of West Virginia a full investigation and that doing nothing despite sufficient evidence of criminal activity 'is unethical'.

    Richard Altizer, who spent his own money testing local water, said dropping the investigation gave the company a license to do what it wanted and left the community without hope.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.