UK tribunal orders government to confirm secret Apple encryption order

RUKUS· · 2d ← 3d
Go Rogue

The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ordered the government to confirm it issued Apple a secret Technical Capability Notice demanding access to encrypted customer data.

The 19 November 2026 ruling rejected the Home Office's claim that confirming the order would damage national security.

The tribunal did not rule on whether the order is lawful or disclose its technical requirements, and a further hearing is expected within a year.

Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals brought the challenge, which is managed alongside Apple's separate claim against the notice.

The government had maintained for two years that it would neither confirm nor deny the order's existence, and Apple was legally barred from disclosing it.

  1. The judgment rests partly on the government's inconsistent use of its neither confirm nor deny policy, including admissions of the notice to reporters and the US government.

    The case is being managed with a second claim by Apple against the notice, and the ruling came from a hearing on whether the government could maintain its neither confirm nor deny policy.

    The challenge was brought by Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals against the lawfulness and secrecy of the Technical Capability Notice regime.

    Unnamed government sources had reportedly confirmed the notice, and US President Trump and his former Director of National Intelligence had openly discussed it, while the government gave no detailed evidence for keeping it secret.

    Privacy International called the ruling a big win for accountability, transparency and online security.

    Privacy International legal director Caroline Wilson Palow called the judgment "a major victory for transparency and effective oversight".

    Caroline Wilson Palow said the tribunal "rightly rejected the UK Government's attempts to shield from scrutiny whether Apple was ordered to undermine the security of our devices, based on an unsupported claim of a risk to national security".

    Caroline Wilson Palow said the government "cannot have its cake and eat it too by claiming secrecy in legal challenges but eschewing it when revelations serve political ends" and that the judgment was the second time this year an inconsistent neither confirm nor deny claim had embarrassed the government.

    Caroline Wilson Palow said Apple had indeed been served with a technical capability notice but that many questions remain, including whether such a secret regime should exist in a democratic society.

  2. The tribunal did not rule that the order was unlawful, did not decide whether the government can require Apple to change its encryption, and did not disclose the notice's technical requirements.

    At a hearing on 17 September 2026, Ben Jaffey KC, representing Liberty and Privacy International, argued the order's existence was already public and secrecy was obstructing the legal challenge.

    The UK government argued at the tribunal that abandoning its neither confirm nor deny policy could help hostile actors identify which companies were subject to such notices.

    The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled: "The respondent has not established that it would be damaging to national security to reveal in these proceedings, as is the case, that the respondent has given Apple a Technical Capability Notice."

    Ben Jaffey KC, representing Liberty and Privacy International, compared the secrecy order to the "emperor's new clothes" and said it "brings the administration of justice into disrepute".

  3. The tribunal rejected the UK Home Office's claim that disclosing the order would be damaging to national security.

    Before the ruling, Apple was legally barred from disclosing the UK order even after its details leaked.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.