US envoys warn current Ukraine peace talks round could be the last chance for a deal
Weekend Update #212: The Clock Is Ticking
Zelensky says Ukraine has yet to see written commitments on NATO-style security guarantees
EN DIRECT, guerre en Ukraine | L’Elysée évoque une adhésion à l’OTAN du pays et réclame une pleine place pour les Européens dans les négociations
Europe will 'closely engage' in peace negotiations between Russia, Ukraine, von der Leyen says
Ukraine war briefing: US proposes Kyiv cede land to Russia for Nato membership, Zelenskyy says
EN DIRECT, guerre en Ukraine : Volodymyr Zelensky affirme que les Etats-Unis ont évoqué des concessions territoriales en échange d’une adhésion à l’OTAN
Security guarantees for Ukraine must also be acceptable to Russia, Rubio says
US-mediated talks on the Russia-Ukraine war opened in Abu Dhabi on November 10, with the Kremlin sending senior diplomats and military officials and Europe represented through officials from leading governments, NATO, and the EU. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said any post-war security guarantees for Ukraine would need to be acceptable to Russia and would be essential to a settlement, though no final plan had been settled on.
American emissaries Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow and then Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in Dublin. Zelensky said the United States had for the first time raised ceding Ukrainian territory in exchange for NATO membership, asking whether Ukraine would withdraw from the Donbas to join the alliance. He said he was not ready to concede territory but would put the Donbas question to a national referendum if Ukraine received security guarantees, a strong and well-funded army, and reconstruction funds. He rejected any commitment to neutrality and dismissed Russia's call for a broad European security agreement before specifics are agreed, and accused SpaceX of restricting Ukraine's Starshield satellite system for five days, which Kyiv suspects is deliberate US pressure. Washington and NATO had not commented on the proposed swap.
At a summit in Berlin on November 19, Kushner told European leaders that Washington was open to security guarantees for Ukraine modeled on NATO's Article 5 collective defense provision. Zelensky said on November 21 he had yet to see written commitments on how such guarantees would work, and that without NATO membership Ukraine would need an army of around one million personnel to defend itself. Russia has rejected the idea of NATO-style guarantees.
On November 22, Witkoff and Kushner warned their Russian and Ukrainian counterparts that the current round of talks could be the last realistic opportunity for a deal before political dynamics in Washington shift. A person familiar with the talks said the warning reflects concern that Russia's leverage could diminish as Democrats move closer to taking control of Congress, bringing renewed pressure to boost aid to Ukraine. Donald Trump met Putin at a summit in Shenzhen and said afterward that Putin wants the war ended by diplomatic means.
US-mediated peace talks on the Russia-Ukraine war were scheduled to take place in Abu Dhabi on November 10-11, 2026.
The Kremlin said it would send senior diplomats and military officials to the US-mediated peace talks in Abu Dhabi.
A senior EU diplomat confirmed Europe would be represented at the negotiations by officials from leading national governments, NATO, and the EU.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said any post-war security guarantees for Ukraine would need to be acceptable to Russia and would be essential to a negotiated settlement to end the war.
Rubio said no final concrete plan has been settled on for what NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine would look like, though concepts have been discussed.
Rubio said such guarantees could potentially be formalized through a treaty, but that this had not been discussed at that level of detail given the difficulty of securing Senate approval.
Rubio said Washington could facilitate the talks and inject ideas but could not guarantee an agreement, stressing that the United States is not a combatant in the war.
Rubio said the United States will continue its diplomatic efforts despite the lack of a breakthrough.
Rubio said security guarantees would be critical for Kyiv to accept a potential peace agreement, since Ukraine must feel secure after the war for the fighting to end.
EN DIRECT, guerre en Ukraine : Volodymyr Zelensky affirme que les Etats-Unis ont évoqué des concessions territoriales en échange d’une adhésion à l’OTAN
US emissaries Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow and then Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in Dublin on November 12, 2026.
Zelensky said the United States had, for the first time, raised ceding Ukrainian territory in exchange for NATO membership, asking at the end of the Abu Dhabi talks whether Ukraine would withdraw from the Donbas if it joined the alliance.
Zelensky said Ukraine is not willing to withdraw its troops from the small part of the Donbas still under its control.
Zelensky said Kyiv is not ready to concede territory, but that if Ukraine receives a comprehensive package of security guarantees, the right to a strong and well-funded army, and reconstruction funds, he would put the question of ceding Donbas territory to a national referendum.
Zelensky dismissed Russia's call for a broad agreement on European security architecture to be reached before the specifics of ending the war in Ukraine are agreed.
Zelensky rejected any Ukrainian commitment to neutrality, which could only happen if the country's constitution was changed.
The Abu Dhabi negotiations produced agreements that European countries would join future talks on ending the war in Ukraine.
Zelensky accused SpaceX of restricting Ukraine's Starshield satellite system for five days, which Kyiv suspects is deliberate US pressure on him to concede to Putin.
Washington and NATO had not commented on the suggestion of swapping Donbas territory for Ukraine's NATO membership.
Zelensky said of the American proposal, "The Americans raised a question: What if Ukraine joins Nato? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?"
Zelensky said suggestions like trading Donbas territory for NATO membership are dangerous because they lead to wars or escalations, and could allow Russia to weaken NATO and reshape borders.
Zelensky said, "That is why I believe Nato is back on the agenda."
Zelensky said, "We cannot turn everything upside down and start by talking about changing the security framework in the world or across the continent overall, and only then talk about ending this war. This war must be ended first."
Zelensky said, "If Putin expects Ukraine's neutrality to be enshrined, that's not going to happen. We're not in Nato right now anyway."
Kushner said the United States is focused on facilitating direct engagement between Russia and European nations on the Ukraine war, after trilateral meetings involving Washington, Moscow, and Kyiv earlier in the week.
Ursula von der Leyen said on November 15, 2026, after speaking with Finnish President Alexander Stubb, that Europe will actively participate in future peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine.
Von der Leyen wrote on X that Europe will closely engage in the peace process through the E5 plus EU format.
Von der Leyen wrote that in the meantime Europe will ensure maximum support for Ukraine and maximum pressure on Russia.
EN DIRECT, guerre en Ukraine | L’Elysée évoque une adhésion à l’OTAN du pays et réclame une pleine place pour les Européens dans les négociations
A summit in Berlin on November 19, 2026 brought together Kyiv's allies, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, and American emissaries Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, as Washington considered security guarantees for Ukraine.
The French presidency set two requirements for responding to Vladimir Putin's invitation to talks in Moscow: a common position among Kyiv, Washington, and the Europeans, and full European participation in the negotiations, with the Europeans actively taking part in the next round alongside the United States and Ukraine.
The French presidency said providing Kyiv with protection comparable to that provided for by the North Atlantic Treaty would amount to Ukraine's membership of NATO, which France defends, saying that once Article 5-type guarantees are given to Ukraine, "one says that Ukraine enters NATO."
A French presidential adviser said the unity of Ukrainians, Americans, and Europeans must be verified, because experience shows it is not always as solid as could be wished.
US envoy Jared Kushner said during talks with European leaders in Berlin on November 19, 2026 that Washington was open to providing Ukraine with security guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5 collective defense provision.
Zelensky said on November 21, 2026 that he has yet to see written commitments outlining how the proposed NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine would work.
Zelensky said Ukraine still needs clarity on what exactly the proposed Article 5-like commitments would entail.
Zelensky said that without NATO membership Ukraine would need to maintain an army of around one million personnel, along with sufficient aircraft, artillery, missiles, and air defense capabilities to defend itself independently.
Zelensky acknowledged that Ukraine's NATO accession remains uncertain, with the outcome depending on how and when Russia's war ends.
Zelensky said, "Article 5 is collective defense. What remains unclear for Ukraine is who exactly this collective would consist of, how it would defend us, and whether it would be prepared to repel the aggressor."
Zelensky said, "The answers must not simply be words, however eloquently they may sound, that 'of course, nobody will abandon you.' This must be on paper. So far, I have not seen such commitments on paper."
Zelensky said, "We need guarantees not for two years, but preferably forever. At least for decades," stressing that any guarantees must remain effective beyond Donald Trump's time in office.
Zelensky said NATO membership remains Ukraine's preferred security guarantee, arguing that joining the alliance would strengthen NATO and reduce the cost of Ukraine's defense, and that, "All of this will certainly exist if Ukraine becomes a NATO member, but it will definitely be cheaper for everyone."
Russia has rejected the idea of NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine.
US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner warned their Russian and Ukrainian counterparts that the current round of peace talks could be the last realistic opportunity to secure a deal before political dynamics in Washington shift.
A person familiar with the talks said the envoys' warning reflects concerns that Russia's leverage could diminish as Democrats move closer to taking control of Congress, triggering renewed bipartisan pressure to increase military and financial assistance to Ukraine and intensify scrutiny of the Trump administration's dealings with the Kremlin.
Donald Trump met Putin at a summit in Shenzhen, after which he said Putin wants the Russia-Ukraine war ended by diplomatic means.
Phillips P. O'Brien wrote that the Trump administration is trying to force Ukraine and Europe to accept a Putin-friendly deal before the new US Congress sits on January 3, 2027, and suggested that if Putin were offered all the Donbas he might agree to a ceasefire, though such a deal would split Ukraine, wipe out its present defensive line, and give Russia a chance to rebuild and attack again.
Trump said of Putin after the Shenzhen summit, "He clearly expressed his desire to see the war between Russia and Ukraine end by diplomatic means."
Trump said at the White House, "President Putin would like to get this settled and that's with surety."
Kushner said in Berlin, "I think we've gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5," adding that the Russians say their intention is to not have another war in the future.
O'Brien called Kushner's presentation of Putin as an honest partner for peace "complete BS."
O'Brien said the clock is ticking on the unchecked power of the Trump administration, that the administration is in close to panic mode and pressuring Ukrainians and Europeans into catastrophic concessions to reward Putin before the new Congress sits, and that the opposite of Rubio's claim that guarantees must be acceptable to Russia is the case.
O'Brien forecast that the administration's push will likely fail, saying the upcoming change in Congress is going to hit the administration hard, and that it knows it.
