Nearly 100,000 kept in housing after judge blocks HUD homelessness funding shift
A federal judge has struck down the Trump administration's 2026 overhaul of federal homelessness funding, blocking the Department of Housing and Urban Development from steering money away from permanent housing programs. U.S. District Judge Mary McElroy in Providence, Rhode Island ruled on November 20 that HUD unlawfully tried to remake the more than 4 billion dollar Continuum of Care program by setting aside 1.3 billion dollars for transitional housing and supportive-services projects favored by the administration.
McElroy found HUD exceeded its authority under the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act by adding criteria that let it bypass requirements to evaluate existing projects and move people into permanent housing. She struck down provisions that penalized providers for not mandating services as a condition of housing, that discouraged harm-reduction practices such as needle exchanges, and that let HUD disqualify applicants judged not to promote self-sufficiency, including organizations that connect homeless people with Medicaid, food stamps, and Supplemental Security Income.
The case was brought by 22 mostly Democratic-led states, the District of Columbia, and groups including the National Alliance to End Homelessness, which renewed their challenge on different grounds after an earlier appellate ruling. McElroy ordered HUD to let applicants amend and resubmit grant applications through December 1 and award funding by December 31.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the agency reserves the right to appeal. On November 22 the National Alliance to End Homelessness said nearly 100,000 formerly homeless people were potentially saved from returning to the streets, a figure its CEO Ann Oliva had earlier warned were at risk of losing housing. It is McElroy's third ruling against HUD's homelessness overhaul.
Federal Court Strikes Down Trump-Vance Administration’s Unlawful Restrictions on Homelessness Funding
The U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island ruled for the plaintiffs in National Alliance to End Homelessness v. HUD, striking down key provisions of the administration's 2026 overhaul of federal homelessness funding.
The court found the Department of Housing and Urban Development exceeded its statutory authority by imposing funding criteria that prioritized the administration's policy agenda over requirements Congress had set.
The ruling blocks HUD from setting aside 1.3 billion dollars in federal funding to prioritize new transitional housing and supportive-services projects at the expense of existing permanent housing programs.
The court struck down criteria that penalized providers for not mandating services as a condition of housing and provisions that discouraged harm-reduction practices.
The decision requires HUD to allow applicants to reapply for certain categories of funding, which must now be awarded based on lawful criteria.
A coalition of states and homelessness and housing groups had challenged HUD's 2026 Continuum of Care funding requirements, which sought to shift federal resources away from permanent housing programs toward approaches favored by the administration.
The plaintiffs argued the new criteria threatened existing housing programs, undermined local communities' ability to respond to homelessness, and exceeded HUD's legal authority.
Democracy Forward called the decision a significant victory for communities and organizations working to address homelessness and protect access to safe, stable housing.
The coalition of plaintiffs welcomed the ruling, saying federal housing resources should help people find safety and stability, not impose a political agenda on organizations doing lifesaving work.
The coalition of plaintiffs said the decision protects the ability of communities and service providers to compete fairly for essential funding without being penalized for providing permanent housing, respecting the needs of domestic violence survivors, or using evidence-based practices, and that these resources are too important to be tied to arbitrary and unlawful restrictions.
U.S. District Judge Mary McElroy in Providence, Rhode Island ruled that the administration unlawfully attempted to overhaul a 4 billion dollar homelessness program by steering funding away from permanent housing assistance toward temporary housing and supportive services.
After an earlier appellate ruling, 22 mostly Democratic-led states, the District of Columbia, and a coalition of homelessness and housing advocacy groups including the National Alliance to End Homelessness renewed their challenge on different grounds.
The renewed challenge targeted HUD's plan to set aside 1.3 billion dollars of the more than 4 billion dollars Congress appropriated for fiscal year 2026 for transitional housing and supportive service-only grants.
McElroy found HUD exceeded its authority under the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act by adding criteria that effectively let it bypass requirements to evaluate existing projects' performance and move people into permanent housing.
McElroy ordered HUD to let applicants amend and resubmit grant applications through December 1 and to award funding by December 31.
McElroy struck down a restriction on grant recipients engaging in activities targeting drug users such as needle exchanges and a provision allowing HUD to disqualify applicants that do not adequately promote self-sufficiency.
Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner said the agency reserves the right to appeal the ruling.
In her ruling, Judge Mary McElroy wrote, 'Although Congress delegated to the secretary the power to create additional criteria for awarding funds, this residual clause cannot be read as allowing HUD to nullify the other congressionally established mandatory factors.'
Secretary Scott Turner said the ruling 'disrupts $4 billion for our most vulnerable, just days before funding awards were set to be made.'
Secretary Scott Turner said, 'Under President Trump, HUD is no longer in the business of throwing taxpayers' money at a status quo that has repeatedly failed America's most vulnerable.'
The National Alliance to End Homelessness said nearly 100,000 formerly homeless people were potentially saved from being returned to the streets after the federal ruling blocked the funding rewrite.
National Alliance to End Homelessness CEO Ann Oliva had warned the funding shift put as many as 97,000 people who had escaped homelessness at risk of losing their housing.
The ruling also stopped HUD from penalizing organizations that connect homeless people with Medicaid, food stamps, and Supplemental Security Income, which HUD had cast as a matter of self-sufficiency.
Organizations engaged in harm reduction, such as those running safe injection sites, are likewise shielded from penalties under the ruling.
The ruling is Judge Mary McElroy's third against HUD's homelessness overhaul.
National Alliance to End Homelessness CEO Ann Oliva said, 'On behalf of communities across the nation working to address homelessness, we applaud this decision,' adding, 'The core of this fight is about the effectiveness of permanent supportive housing' and 'Safe and affordable housing ends people's homelessness.'
Housing Secretary Scott Turner said HUD's 'Treatment First' mission will not be deterred.
