Ron Johnson says he is not proposing to shut down Social Security

RUKUS· · 2d ← 3d
Go Rogue

Republican Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin called Social Security a Ponzi scheme on Fox Business and said it should be shut down.

He told a Senate Budget Committee hearing his comments were imprecise and that he is not proposing to shut the program down.

He says he wants a law guaranteeing seniors' benefits and wants Congress to address $24 trillion of 10-year deficits instead.

Experts and Democrats defended the program, saying its trust funds are legitimate and benefits have been paid for 91 years.

Johnson, who is up for reelection in 2028, faces criticism that the remarks will appear in Democratic campaign ads.

  1. Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, called Ron Johnson's call to end Social Security a brazen effort, in broad daylight, to steal Americans' earned benefits.

    Stephen Nuñez, director of stratification economics at the Roosevelt Institute, called Ron Johnson's claim that there is no way to fix Social Security complete horseshit.

    Ned Resnikoff, an independent policy analyst, predicted Ron Johnson's attacks on Social Security will end poorly for him when he runs for reelection in 2028.

  2. Senator Catherine Cortez Masto said Americans have paid into Social Security with every paycheck and that she will not let Senate Republicans like Ron Johnson gut benefits seniors earned over a lifetime of work.

    Michael Linden of the Center for Equitable Growth called Ron Johnson's remarks politically toxic and totally wrong substantively, saying the funding gap over the four decades after 2026 is about 1.25% of GDP.

    The activist group Social Security Works said Ron Johnson wants to shut Social Security down, and that any Republicans who will not commit to making billionaires pay their fair share agree with him.

    Democratic strategist Matt McDermott said Ron Johnson, the top red-to-blue Senate flip opportunity in 2028, wants to shut down Social Security.

    The Independent's Eric Michael Garcia predicted Ron Johnson's remarks are coming to a Democratic campaign ad in Wisconsin.

    Matt Yglesias said he understands why most Republicans favor cutting Social Security over higher taxes but does not understand how Ron Johnson's proposal to shut it down and hope to recover some of the money is supposed to work.

    Jon Favreau, co-host of Pod Save America, joked that Ron Johnson's Social Security remarks are a strong start to his 2028 re-election campaign.

  3. On Fox Business on November 18, Ron Johnson said there is really no way to fix Social Security, called it a Ponzi scheme, and said the government should just shut it down and hope people recover some of their money.

    Ron Johnson said on Fox Business that Social Security benefits are paid by recipients' children and grandchildren and by money borrowed from the public.

  4. Ron Johnson told Newsmax that the SEC defines a Ponzi scheme as a fraudulent investment paying early investors with current investors, and said that is exactly what Social Security does.

    Walter Einenkel wrote that Ron Johnson, by attacking one of the most popular programs in United States history, seems to be starting his reelection campaign early.

  5. Ron Johnson told the Senate Budget Committee hearing on November 19 that he is not proposing to shut down Social Security, calling his earlier comments imprecise.

    Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon told the Senate Budget Committee hearing that this is the first time in decades a committee chairman said he would rather shut down Social Security than fix it.

  6. At the hearing, Ron Johnson said he wants lawmakers to pass a law ensuring seniors' benefits are not reduced, and to fix what he called the real problem, $24 trillion of 10-year deficits.

    At the hearing, Ron Johnson held up a picture of the Social Security trust funds, which he called a four-drawer file in Parkersburg, West Virginia.

    Bill Sweeney, senior vice president of government affairs at AARP, said Social Security is not part of the budget and runs on its own budget, and called Ron Johnson's description out of touch with how Americans understand the program.

    Jason Fichtner, a witness at the hearing and executive director of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute, called the Senate Budget Committee hearing a missed opportunity for a deeper discussion of Social Security's challenges.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.