Judge lets most of Trump's $15 billion defamation suit against the New York Times proceed

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flmd.447437/gov.uscourts.flmd.447437.109.0.pdf

courtlistener.com· · 2d
Open

A federal judge in Florida partly denies the New York Times Company's motion to dismiss President Donald Trump's defamation suit, ruling that most of the twenty-seven challenged statements are not actionable but that seven may proceed. In those seven, the court finds the complaint plausibly alleges that the authors and publishers of the book 'Lucky Loser' and related reporting knew their accusations of complex tax crimes rested on incomplete information and knowingly failed to obtain the qualified expert opinion any reliable conclusion would require, which the court calls purposeful avoidance of the truth under New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. The court grants the motion as to Counts III and IV, denies it as to Counts I, II, V, and VI, rejects Trump's request to amend again as futile, and orders the defendants to answer within twenty-eight days.

Trump’s case against NYT and Penguin Random House may proceed: Judge

aljazeera.com· · 2d
Open

A federal judge has ruled that Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House may proceed, a victory in his legal campaign against media companies he accuses of unfair treatment. Judge Steven Merryday threw out two of Trump's claims but found the rest plausibly alleged that statements accusing him of planning and perpetrating complex crimes were based on incomplete, minimal information. The suit concerns two articles and a book that cast doubt on Trump's origin story as a savvy businessman, and the defendants deny defaming him, telling the court his case is legally flawed and aimed at scoring political points. The ruling comes days after another judge allowed Trump's $10bn defamation lawsuit against the BBC to move forward.

NYT's 'smells like a crime' defense collapses in Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit

rawstory.com· · 2d
Open

In a Thursday ruling in Tampa, U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday found the expert backing for New York Times reporters' tax fraud accusations against President Donald Trump fell short, letting his $15 billion defamation lawsuit move forward. The George H.W. Bush appointee denied the motion to dismiss four of six counts against the Times, its reporters, and Penguin Random House, with the surviving claims centering on seven statements, six of them from the book 'Lucky Loser' accusing Trump of tax fraud and one from a Times article saying authorities looked into his Mafia ties. The defendants had pointed to experts quoted in a 2018 Times investigation, including one who said the Trump family's arrangement "smells like a crime," but Merryday called such input "far from a formal legal opinion," writing that knowing a formal legal opinion is needed yet failing to get one is a knowing failure that remains actionable even after Times v. Sullivan. He still threw out 27 other statements as not actionable even if untrue, dismissed two counts, and gave the defendants 28 days to answer. The Times has called the lawsuit meritless and an attempt to stifle independent reporting, while a spokesperson for Trump's legal team called the ruling a victory for honesty in America.

US ⁠judge allows Trump’s $15bn lawsuit against New York Times to proceed

theguardian.com· · 2d
Open

A federal judge in Florida has ruled that Donald Trump's $15bn defamation lawsuit against the New York Times and the publisher Penguin Random House may proceed. US district judge Steven Merryday in Tampa dismissed two claims while letting the core defamation claims move forward, saying the remaining complaint plausibly alleged that statements accusing Trump of 'planning and perpetrating complex crimes' rested on incomplete information. The suit targets three Times reporters over two articles and the 2024 book 'Lucky Loser', and Trump claims their statements were false and damaged his businesses and reputation. An earlier 80-page complaint was thrown out for lacking a concise summary and being filled with 'vituperation and invective', and the amended 40-page version followed failed mediation; the defendants deny defaming Trump and call the case meritless.

Judge lets Trump’s libel lawsuit against New York Times reporters proceed

politico.com· · 2d
Open

A federal judge is letting President Trump move forward with part of his $15 billion libel lawsuit against The New York Times, its reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, and Penguin Random House over the book 'Lucky Loser' and reporting on his business and financial dealings. Judge Steven Merryday ruled on 19 November 2026 that statements suggesting Trump had likely committed complex tax crimes appeared to rest on insufficient input from qualified experts, though the ruling does not conclude the book defamed him, only that his allegations are plausible enough to proceed. He threw out the parts of the suit targeting statements in Times articles by Buettner, Craig, and Peter Baker, and he weighed the high 'actual malice' bar set by New York Times v. Sullivan, writing that publishers who assert complex crimes without a qualified opinion 'know that they don't know, but they are undeterred.' Trump's legal team called the ruling a victory, and both sides are expected to seek judgment after discovery, with a jury trial possible.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.