South Carolina parole board denies Susan Smith parole for second time
Susan Smith, serving a life sentence for drowning her sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, in a South Carolina lake in 1994, was denied parole for the second time on Nov. 19, 2026.
The South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons voted unanimously to deny her request and did not explain its reasons.
Smith initially claimed a Black man had abducted the boys, then confessed to strapping them into her car and rolling it into John D. Long Lake.
At the hearing she told the board by video call she has changed and feels remorse, and her attorney said she is receiving treatment for borderline personality disorder.
Her ex-husband David Smith and other family members urged the board to keep her imprisoned, and prosecutors warned she could profit from her story if released.
Under South Carolina law she may seek parole every two years, and her family could face another hearing in 2028.
Susan Smith, who killed her young boys 3 decades ago in a South Carolina lake, is denied parole | CNN
Prosecutors Kevin Brackett and Tommy Pope warned the board that Susan Smith could profit from her crimes if released by selling her story to journalists or through social media.
Officials at the hearing noted that Susan Smith has had no disciplinary infractions since her 2024 parole hearing.
Susan Smith told the board by video call, 'I know that what I did to Michael and Alex is horrible…I have a lot of remorse, and I want to say that I'm very, very sorry.'
Susan Smith told the board, 'They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die.'
David Smith asked the board, 'I'm just here to ask you all to look in your heart and see their father's pain and his still broken heart, and ask your heart: Is 32 years enough for what she did to Michael and Alex?'
Prosecutor Tommy Pope warned the board, 'If you think this family has been through hell now, imagine every day if you pick up your phone or you turn on your computer, and there's Susan talking about that.'
After the decision, David Smith said, 'We are very grateful to the parole board for keeping her incarcerated for another two years.'
After the decision, David Smith said, 'Thank you for keeping Michael and Alex as the focus point.'
The South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons unanimously denied Susan Smith's second request for parole on Nov. 19, 2026, by a 6-0 vote, keeping her in prison for at least two more years.
Susan Smith appeared remotely before the board at her second parole hearing, having first been denied parole in 2024, and testified that she is not the same person she was 32 years ago and carries deep remorse over the unbearable pain she caused.
David Smith told the board it has been 32 years since he buried Michael and Alex and that setting Susan Smith free would be a huge injustice.
Susan Smith told the board, 'I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have changed. I have grown up. I have matured.'
Susan Smith told the board she carries deep remorse over the 'unbearable pain' she caused.
David Smith told the board, 'It's been 32 years since I buried Michael and Alex... I know for some of you 32 years is a long time, but for me it was yesterday.'
David Smith said that setting Susan Smith free 'would be a huge injustice.'
Because South Carolina law allows Susan Smith to seek parole every two years, her family could face another parole hearing in 2028.
David Smith said Susan Smith has never fully told the truth about why she committed the crime and that he remains convinced she killed the boys because she wanted a future with a man who did not want children.
Tiffany Smith said it appeared Susan Smith was 'getting rid of her past so she could be with this man that she wanted to be with'.
Tiffany Smith said, 'We try not to think about her…Michael and Alex is who we think about, and who we honor. Their names are the ones that should be said, not hers'.
David Smith said he is already dreading the next parole hearing and called the process emotionally exhausting.
The board members did not immediately elaborate on the reasons for denying Susan Smith's request.
Susan Smith and her attorney Tommy Thomas told the board she is a changed woman who suffers from borderline personality disorder and is receiving treatment.
Forensic psychiatrist Jesse Hill testified that childhood trauma, including the death of Susan Smith's father and sexual abuse by her stepfather, contributed to her borderline personality disorder, which tends to improve with age.
David Smith was joined in opposing release by his wife Tiffany Smith, their daughter Savannah Smith, state Rep. Tommy Pope, and Union County Solicitor Kevin Brackett.
State Rep. Tommy Pope said Susan Smith needs to remain incarcerated for the rest of her life to give David Smith's family some peace and give Michael and Alex some justice.
Savannah Smith said the emotional toll the killings have taken on David Smith has been immense and that it is not about revenge but about accountability and justice.
Attorney Tommy Thomas said Susan Smith suffers from borderline personality disorder and is receiving treatment.
