Two More Trump-Connected Litigants Move to Continue IRS Payout Lawsuit

RUKUS· · 2d
Go Rogue

Top Trump administration officials intervened to win Shelby Lowman, a golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley, a $500,000 payout from the IRS.

The Justice Department offered $500,000 each to five plaintiffs who accused the IRS and Booz Allen Hamilton of failing to protect their tax information.

The $2.5 million settlement was about 250 times what the law calls for, and IRS lawyers were not consulted on its terms as is standard.

Political appointees Brett Shumate and Joshua Wu delivered the offer before any final court ruling, and a judge has not ruled on the case.

After the settlement, two more people connected to Trump businesses sought to continue the case, and critics fear it could revive Trump's $1.776 billion fund.

Trump's $1.776 billion 'Anti-Weaponization' fund, created after his $10 million IRS lawsuit, was killed by a court order months earlier.

  1. A judge has not ruled on whether the IRS class action can proceed.

    The suit followed the theft of IRS data by contractor Charles Littlejohn, the same grievance behind Donald Trump's separate $10 million lawsuit against the IRS.

    The Justice Department and the IRS declined to comment on the pending case.

    The Trump Organization said it had no involvement in the payout.

  2. Safe Harbor, a company connected to Donald Trump's media business with no website or public presence, was among the five plaintiffs paid $500,000 each.

    The five plaintiffs filed the class action in 2025, accusing the IRS and contractor Booz Allen Hamilton of failing to safeguard their financial information.

  3. After the settlement, two more people connected to Trump businesses, a retired accountant from Shelby Lowman's former Trump property and a former lifeguard, came forward to continue the litigation.

    Brett Shumate, who delivered the payout offer, left the Justice Department in early November and did not respond to requests for comment.

    Before the case reached the fact-finding stage, the Justice Department stopped fighting it and made an offer of judgment in August 2026 to pay the five named plaintiffs $500,000 each.

    The career Justice Department trial attorney on the case did not sign the proposed payout; political appointees Brett Shumate and Joshua Wu delivered it instead.

    IRS Office of Chief Counsel attorneys were not consulted about the settlement terms, contrary to standard practice.

    IRS employees who learned of the $2.5 million offer said it was dramatically higher than the law called for and was not supported by any evidence.

    The settlement total of $2.5 million was about 250 times what the law calls for given the allegations, and multiple officials said such payments almost never approach that size.

    Gil Rothenberg, an American University law professor who led the Justice Department tax division's appellate section for 15 years, said the deal 'is not passing the smell test' and called the amount 'odd and unusual.'

    A White House spokesperson said the Justice Department is 'promoting efficient resolution of cases to avoid extraordinary liability.'

    Former IRS Commissioner John Koskinen, who led the agency from 2013 to 2017, said the settlement 'opens the door to Trump himself benefiting from this settlement,' possibly alongside other Trump allies and friends.

    Linda Nussbaum, a lawyer for plaintiff Belpointe Sleepovation Investment, said it was 'news to me' that the other plaintiffs had 'ties to the Trump administration.'

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.