Lisnard calls primary a way to eliminate the Macronists and sets two conditions

RUKUS· · 8h ← 4d
Go Rogue

The campaign teams of Gabriel Attal of Renaissance, Bruno Retailleau of Les Républicains and David Lisnard of Nouvelle Énergie agreed on 17 November 2026 on the principle of a right-and-centre primary to designate a single candidate for the 2027 presidential election, held in two rounds and as open as possible, likely in late January 2027. Two pairs of dates are under discussion: a first round on 17 January with a second on 24 January, or 24 January with a second on 31 January. Édouard Philippe of Horizons remains invited, and Les Républicains says no one made his presence a precondition, though Renaissance still hopes he takes part, as he leads his camp in the polls. The agreed perimeter would exclude candidates of extreme parties, and participation by the far-right Reconquête is seen as unlikely.

On 18 November the three campaigns' representatives met at the Concorde brasserie near the National Assembly in Paris, working through a common technical team formed around the campaign directors. They endorsed an open primary by electronic voting, with a few physical polling stations per department, a two-euro participation fee for voters, and significant sponsorships required to stand to prevent a proliferation of testimonial candidacies. The representatives are to meet again on 26 or 27 November to settle the remaining modalities, including the rules for candidates and the debates.

On 21 November Lisnard, who has long called for the primary, set two practically unrealizable conditions for holding it: the participation of Édouard Philippe, who categorically refuses it, and of far-right candidate Éric Zemmour, whose participation would be a casus belli for Gabriel Attal. Following his recent breakthrough in opinion polls, Lisnard is suspected of no longer wanting the primary he has always called for, even as he claims otherwise.

  1. The campaign teams of Gabriel Attal of Renaissance, Bruno Retailleau of Les Républicains and David Lisnard of Nouvelle Énergie agreed on 17 November 2026 on the principle of a right-and-centre primary held in two rounds and as open as possible, likely in late January 2027, to which Édouard Philippe of Horizons remains invited.

    Two pairs of dates are under discussion for the primary: a first round on 17 January 2027 with a second on 24 January, or a first round on 24 January with a second on 31 January.

    Under the perimeter agreed by the three teams, the primary would exclude candidates of extreme parties, and participation by the far-right party Reconquête is seen as unlikely.

    Les Républicains says no one made Édouard Philippe's presence a precondition and that the primary could take place without him, while Renaissance still hopes Philippe, who leads his camp in the polls, will take part.

    A two-euro participation fee for voters is envisaged for the primary.

    The representatives of the three candidates are to meet again on 26 or 27 November 2026 to discuss the remaining modalities, including the rules candidates must follow, the sponsorships required to stand and the debates.

    David Lisnard said on TF1 that pressure must be put on Édouard Philippe, because accepting competition without him would let Philippe stay quietly on his Aventine and leave doubt over whether the primary is even organised.

    David Lisnard said he is incapable of saying whether the primary will take place, that he proposes it because he believes in competition rather than compromise, and that it must be broad and not a trap.

    A Horizons official said of the primary organisers: 'we won't go, but they are convinced we will crack'.

    David Lisnard judged on 18 November 2026 that the participation of Édouard Philippe, the head of Horizons, is indispensable.

    Jordan Bardella, president of the Rassemblement national, mocked on X the 'backroom deals' between 'the openly Macronist' Gabriel Attal, 'the converted Macronist' Bruno Retailleau and 'the masked Macronist' David Lisnard.

  2. Representatives of Gabriel Attal, Bruno Retailleau and David Lisnard met at the Concorde brasserie near the National Assembly in Paris to advance the organisation of a potential primary whose goal is to designate a single candidate of the right and centre for the 2027 presidential election.

    The three campaigns already have a common technical team formed around the campaign directors.

    The three parties endorsed an open primary held by electronic voting, except for a few physical polling stations per department.

    A significant number of sponsorships will be required to stand in the primary, to prevent a proliferation of testimonial candidacies.

    Othman Nasrou, secretary general of Les Républicains, said the exchanges were very constructive.

  3. Right after the meeting of campaign directors, David Lisnard denied his colleagues' assertion that a principle agreement had been found for a primary.

    A supporter of Gabriel Attal said in a statement read on the show: 'There is urgency in the rallying of the democrats of the right and the centre; our candidates are collapsing.'

    David Lisnard said the primary competition must be as broad as possible, including Gabriel Attal even though some call him a socialist, provided it respects criteria to be worked out with Nicolas Dupont-Aignan and Reconquête, and that Édouard Philippe is indispensable.

    Bruno Le Maire, not yet a declared candidate, answered 'why not' when a possible primary was raised at his programme presentation.

    Nils of Le Média said he doubts David Lisnard really wants a primary while the Lisnard camp rides a poll-driven momentum.

    Jean-Bernard Gayoranucci said he is not convinced David Lisnard really wants a primary and that he does not see a central-bloc agreement coming, since every announced start of an accord is denied in the following days by one candidate or another.

    Jean-Bernard Gayoranucci suggested it might be better if the divorce happened now or by January, so that one or two remaining candidates could truly campaign.

    Jean-Bernard Gayoranucci said nothing guarantees that David Lisnard's supporters would vote for Édouard Philippe if he were elected, any more than Philippe's supporters would vote for Lisnard or Bruno Retailleau.

  4. David Lisnard set two practically unrealizable conditions for the primary: the participation of Édouard Philippe of Horizons, who categorically refuses it, and of far-right candidate Éric Zemmour, whose participation would be a casus belli for Gabriel Attal.

    Following his recent breakthrough in opinion polls, David Lisnard is suspected of no longer wanting the primary he has always called for, even as he claims otherwise.

    In an interview with the Journal du Dimanche, David Lisnard said: 'I see this primary as the pre-first round of the presidential election. It is a matter of eliminating the macronists and the candidates who scatter votes before the first round.'

    In the same interview, David Lisnard said he will not necessarily support the primary's winner because he does not want to compromise with people he would not govern with, adding: 'I will not, for that matter, ask Mr. Gabriel Attal to support me if I win.'

    David Lisnard said of Bruno Retailleau: 'I think Mr. Retailleau and I are close and that we could work together.'

    David Lisnard said that if Édouard Philippe did not take part in the primary, 'we would have all the disadvantages of a primary without the advantage of a real selection.'

    David Lisnard said Eric Zemmour's party, Reconquête!, 'should also be able to compete in the primary if it respects its conditions of access.'

    David Lisnard's rivals accuse him, like Eric Ciotti, of favoring 'the union of the rights'.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.