Google rejects UK call to remove Russell Brand video as Prime Minister urges decency
British PM tells Google to remove Russell Brand video
New law ‘may be needed’ after Google rejects call to remove Russell Brand’s YouTube prison message
Russell Brand video still on YouTube despite ministers demanding removal
UK government asks for Russell Brand's YouTube account to be removed
UK government reportedly asks for Russell Brand’s YouTube account to be deactivated
Russell Brand is serving a sentence of 10 and a half years for rape and three counts of sexual assault.
His wife Laura read a message from him claiming innocence on their YouTube channel, prompting an investigation into prison rules.
The UK government asked Google to deactivate Brand's YouTube account and remove the video, but Google refused, saying its rules were not broken.
The video remains online and had been viewed more than 950,000 times by Friday.
Ministers say the Online Safety Act does not cover prisoners broadcasting on social media, and a new law may be needed.
Meta earlier disabled Brand's profiles on Instagram and Facebook.
No criminal offence was committed in releasing the video, as prisoners are allowed to protest their innocence.
The request to Google followed Meta's decision to disable Russell Brand's profiles on Instagram and Facebook.
The UK government asked Google to remove Russell Brand's YouTube account after his wife posted a video carrying his message.
A UK justice minister met representatives of Google, which owns YouTube, to make the removal request.
Brand's message prompted an investigation into whether he broke prison rules.
On Sunday, Laura Brand read a handwritten message from her husband on their YouTube channel in which he claimed he was not guilty of the offences.
Downing Street called Russell Brand's prison message "clearly appalling", saying prisoners are strictly banned from statements that distress victims.
Education Secretary Lucy Powell criticised media outlets for playing extracts of the message, saying they should not have "amplified" his words.
Google rejected a UK government request, made via the Prison Service, to take down Russell Brand's prison message video, which had almost 850,000 views.
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook said prisoners are already banned from making statements to the media and that Ministry of Justice ministers had asked Google to remove the specific video.
A Google spokesperson said its teams are investigating the new content, and that the channel was suspended from the YouTube partner program in September 2023 and has not been able to monetise since.
Labour MP Jess Phillips forecast that a new online safety act is very likely to be needed to tackle convicted criminals broadcasting from prison.
Jess Phillips said voluntary codes for tech companies are "the triumph of hope over experience" and that Google leaving the video up shows those codes are not good enough.
Children and families minister Josh MacAlister said he hopes Google makes the same decision that Meta has.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said she would not start from immediately demanding private platforms take down content when no law has been broken, though she is concerned about prisoners using conduits to send messages.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham urged Google to remove the video, calling on social media companies to take it down and saying Brand's victims have heard quite enough from him.
The video remained accessible on Russell and Laura Brand's YouTube channel, which has more than 6.6 million subscribers, and had been viewed more than 950,000 times as of Friday.
Google said it had refused the UK government's removal request because its rules had not been broken.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham called on social media companies to "take these interviews down", saying Brand's victims "shouldn't be hearing from him".
Andy Burnham said, "I would first say to the social media companies show some responsibility here. Think of the victims, that's the main thing. Show some decency", and stopped short of changing the law on prisoner broadcasts, saying, "I wouldn't leap to that".
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook said the government has no power to force removal and "that is up to Google", adding, "We've made a request in this instance because we feel very strongly that victims shouldn't have to see this content".
A UK ministry spokesman said, "It is only right that the government asks for content that is distressing for victims to be taken down, and we strongly believe YouTube should remove this content".
