UN talks end without ban on killer robots, agreeing only to draft rules by 2028
Why have UN efforts to regulate ‘killer robots’ stalled?
It will soon be too late to regulate use of autonomous weapons, warns Red Cross
The UN fails to agree on rules regulating ‘killer robots’
Killer robots: U.N. talks fall short of hopes for legally binding rules
International talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse
A Genève, la communauté internationale échoue à interdire les robots tueurs
Nations agree to ‘elaborate’ on rules for AI-run ‘killer robots’ by 2028
Nations at UN talks on AI killer robots agree to more talks but no firm commitment to rein them in
Countries agree to U.N. talks aiming to regulate 'killer robots' by 2028
Killerroboter: UN-Konferenz endet mit Minimalkonsens
States agree to UN talks aiming to regulate 'killer robots' by 2028
"Robots tueurs" : un accord à l'ONU ouvre la voie à l'élaboration de règles internationales
UN negotiations among 128 member states in Geneva ended before dawn on Saturday 21 November without a ban on lethal autonomous weapons, agreeing only to work toward draft rules by 2028.
Around 100 countries backed legally binding rules, but the United States, Russia and Israel opposed them, favoring national guidelines instead. The United States proposed a five-year window for a nonbinding mandate, and other defence tech powers including South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France and Germany also resisted being bound by new law.
Russia obstructed the talks from their opening on Monday, first objecting to the agenda and then to rules of procedure, forcing the cancellation of formal meetings and pushing exchanges into an informal framework. A diplomat said the delegations' positions drew closer over the week, but diplomats inside the talks said Russia was deliberately filibustering and not working in good faith. After an all-night session wrangling over a handful of words, efforts to agree a negotiating mandate collapsed just before 5 a.m. on Saturday.
At 4:30 a.m., diplomats announced a compromise: no deal within a year, and rules that could be legally binding or optional. Conference president Julien Thöni said states agreed to launch work on an international instrument over the next two years, with some countries accepting the word elaborate instead of negotiate, a mandate that may carry no legal obligations. Government experts are to propose further elements by 2028, including whether these should lead to a binding treaty.
Support for binding rules ran wide: 163 of 193 UN member states voted for negotiations, and 95 of the 128 parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons backed a treaty ensuring autonomous weapons comply with international humanitarian law. An earlier proposal by Brazil, Austria, Belgium, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama to launch negotiations fell short, and Secretary-General António Guterres had hoped for a binding deal in 2026.
The talks had been billed as a last chance to regulate weapons whose technology may not even be fully understood, and they now remain unregulated for at least two years.
Negotiations among 128 UN member states on regulating lethal autonomous weapons ended in Geneva on 21 November 2026 with a commitment to continue discussions toward new rules within two years.
A majority of states favored a legally binding agreement on lethal autonomous weapons, but the United States and Russia, which hold the technology, opposed it.
Conference president Julien Thöni said the states party to the review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to launch work on an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons over the next two years, with some countries accepting the word elaborate instead of negotiate.
Moscow's opposition to the participation of observers, notably the European Union, hampered the Geneva negotiations from their opening on Monday and forced states to continue their exchanges in an informal framework.
A diplomat said the positions of the delegations drew closer over the course of the week.
Julien Thöni said the coming discussions must clarify which weapons can be banned under international humanitarian law and which are not banned but can be regulated.
The Stop Killer Robots coalition said states adopted a watered-down mandate that does not really open the way to a legally binding instrument.
Nicole van Rooijen said delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity in danger.
Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch judged the outcome disappointing, saying it does not provide the urgent measures needed while the technology advances at full speed.
Brazilian ambassador Frederico Meyer said some countries hold the power while others hold the majority, as is the case at the Geneva conference, and that what is at stake is the search for a solution.
Around 100 countries backed legally binding rules for autonomous weapons, while the United States, Russia and Israel opposed them, favoring national guidelines instead.
The Geneva talks concluded after 4 a.m. on Saturday following an all-night session in which diplomats wrangled over a handful of words after Russian objections to rules of procedure forced the cancellation of some formal meetings.
Swiss chair Julien Thoeni hailed the deal as a significant achievement for humanitarian disarmament after more than 10 years of talks, saying, 'It shows that even in today's deeply divided world, multilateral diplomacy can still deliver concrete results.'
A diplomat from a country supporting new laws called the outcome 'disappointing but could have been much worse'.
Many rights groups criticized the outcome, which they said means technology now has a chance to overtake diplomacy.
The 128 states parties failed to give a concrete mandate for negotiations on a legally binding ban on fully autonomous weapons.
Government experts are to discuss and propose further elements for an agreement by 2028, including whether these should later lead to a legally binding treaty.
Magnus Lovold of Lex International warned the world faces an 'Oppenheimer moment', saying, 'We are now really at a point where it could become much more difficult in the future to get the rules we need.'
Non-governmental organizations such as Stop Killer Robots called the result a disappointing outcome on the lowest common denominator.
U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres, many countries and activists had sought legally binding rules, and Guterres had hoped for a legally binding deal in 2026.
An earlier proposal by Brazil, Austria, Belgium, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama to launch negotiations on a rulebook limiting machines' ability to kill without human control fell short.
U.N. high representative for disarmament affairs Izumi Nakamitsu hailed the outcome as a 'significant achievement' while acknowledging a 'glass half full or half empty' scenario.
Beatrice Fihn, founder of Lex International, said the Geneva decision amounts to 'pushing the can down the road for two more years'.
Max Tegmark, founder of the Future of Life Institute, said: 'States have agreed it is sufficient to just talk about the issue, for the 14th year, while these weapons enable atrocities.'
Ambassador Frederico Meyer of Brazil said 'Technology is moving faster than diplomacy' and that 'Diplomats are very slow.'
Activists accused military powers like Russia and the United States of blocking stronger language at the Geneva talks.
Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch said, 'It does not provide the urgent action needed to agree new rules – but the technology is racing ahead.'
Of the 128 signatory states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, 95 voted in favor of a treaty ensuring that the use of autonomous weapons complies with international humanitarian law.
163 of 193 UN member states adopted a resolution calling for negotiations on autonomous weapons, with the United States, Russia, Israel, North Korea and Belarus voting against.
Efforts to agree a negotiating mandate for a legally binding treaty on autonomous weapons collapsed just before 5 a.m. on Saturday after all-night talks failed to overcome Russian objections, and the conference adopted a weaker mandate asking countries only to elaborate an instrument by consensus, which may carry no legal obligations.
Russia used obstructive stalling tactics from the opening day, and diplomats inside the negotiations said it was deliberately filibustering and not working in good faith.
The United States proposed a five-year window to sort out a nonbinding mandate, and other defence tech powers including South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France and Germany resisted being bound by new law, advocating a nonbinding agreement instead.
European and NATO states including Ukraine, as well as China and Iran, expressed support or willingness for a new protocol on autonomous weapons.
The United States said the need for human control over autonomous weapons was discussed in meetings between Xi Jinping and Donald Trump that week, while remaining reluctant to agree a binding treaty.
Brazil's delegate told the conference floor that lethal autonomous weapons systems are not weapons of the future but are already in use and being further developed, and that states are late in developing the norms to regulate them.
Bonnie Docherty of Human Rights Watch said treaties on autonomous weapons could be negotiated within 15 months and dismissed the US proposal for five years, saying autonomous weapons need binding law.
Max Tegmark said world leaders failed to meet the moment during the week of the Geneva talks.
Some states argued that international humanitarian law is sufficient to deal with autonomous weapons.
At 4:30 a.m. on Saturday, diplomats announced a compromise: no deal within a year, and rules that could be legally binding or optional, leaving weapons that use artificial intelligence for life-and-death decisions unregulated for at least two years.
The Geneva negotiations had been billed as a last chance to regulate weapons whose technology and decision-making capabilities may not even be fully understood.
On day one of the talks, Russia delayed proceedings by objecting to the meeting's agenda.
The International Committee of the Red Cross immediately said it regretted the move and renewed its appeal for a binding treaty.
Dr Cordula Droege of the International Committee of the Red Cross said artificial intelligence is starting to be fielded in the battlefield and perhaps already in weapon systems, and that if left unregulated it will be much more difficult to put the 'genie back in the bottle'.
Dr Cordula Droege of the ICRC said the aim is not to ban all autonomous weapon systems but to set red lines in an international treaty that should never be crossed, and that targeting human beings through machines should be a moral red line.
Anna Hehir of the Future of Life Institute warned that further delay to a strong treaty could see more mass civilian harm, and that some mass casualty events could dwarf what has already occurred over the past 18 months to two years.
ICRC president Mirjana Spoljaric Egger and U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres have called for a legally binding instrument with clear prohibitions and restrictions on the use of autonomous weapons.
The ICRC called for a ban on the use of autonomous weapons against personnel, for the systems to behave predictably, and for limits restricting their use to military objectives.
Rights groups warned that any delay in regulating autonomous weapons risks allowing private industry and militaries to set the norms of how they are used.
