Cornyn clashes with Heritage Foundation president over blocked Trump judicial nominee

RUKUS· · 2d ← 12d
Go Rogue

Senator John Cornyn of Texas is blocking President Trump's nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser to a Dallas federal judgeship by withholding his blue slip.

Cornyn says Gaiser, an Ohioan who leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, lacks trial experience and skipped the state's screening process.

Under the blue-slip custom, judicial nominees typically need the approval of their home-state senators to advance in the Senate.

Cornyn and Senator Ted Cruz, who supports the nomination, traded shouts on the Senate floor, and Cruz warns the seat will otherwise go to Democrats.

Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts attacked Cornyn, who lost his Texas primary and leaves office as Democrats prepare to take Senate control.

Cornyn has offered the White House an alternative, former prosecutor Steve Fahey, and the White House expects all its nominees confirmed by year's end.

  1. A White House official said Trump was actively considering Gaiser for the federal bench in North Texas.

    A Senate Judiciary Committee aide said committee members received Gaiser's judicial questionnaire on Sunday night, a step that normally follows a formal nomination.

    Gaiser's questionnaire response said the office of Senator Ted Cruz contacted him about the potential judicial opening the day after the election.

    The questionnaire showed Gaiser, a former Ohio solicitor general, had no professional ties to Texas beyond a judicial clerkship he held from 2016 to 2017.

  2. Gaiser's Senate questionnaire included prepared remarks from 2016 documenting his history of campaigning for Ted Cruz.

    According to his questionnaire, Gaiser spoke with staff from Cornyn's office on November 6, 2026, after learning from the White House that he was under consideration for the vacancy.

    Cornyn said he and Cruz had previously recommended other candidates who had gone through Texas's customary judicial screening process.

    Cornyn said trying to "air-drop" someone into the Dallas vacancy at the last minute without going through the screening process was a concern.

  3. Cornyn refused to return the blue slip for Gaiser, withholding the home-state approval judicial nominees typically need to advance, because the candidate lacks ties to Texas.

    Cornyn said of Gaiser, "I just refuse to be jammed by a non-Texan who has no trial experience, who hasn't been vetted."

  4. President Donald Trump nominated T. Elliot Gaiser, head of the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas.

    Cornyn pushed the White House to replace Gaiser days before the Senate hearing, and an aide said he was recommending former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey for the seat instead.

    Cornyn said the White House bypassed the bipartisan screening committee Texas senators use to vet judicial candidates, and raised concerns about Gaiser's role in Trump's 2020 election challenges.

    Conservative actor Matthew Marsden called Cornyn's move "a disgrace".

    In a post on X, Eric Daugherty urged Cornyn, "Let him through!", telling him to "Do the right thing for America!"

    Students for Trump founder Ryan Fournier wrote, "WOW! Sen. John Cornyn is BLOCKING Trump's judicial nominee Elliot Gaiser by withholding his blue slip. A LIFETIME federal judgeship is now caught in a GOP standoff!"

    Claremont Institute senior fellow Jeremy Carl wrote, "Gaiser is one of the best possible GOP judicial picks. So it makes sense that Cornyn would oppose him."

  5. The nomination came as Republicans scrambled to confirm Trump's judicial picks before Democrats take control of the Senate and the confirmation process stalls.

  6. Cornyn dismissed Cruz's reply with an expletive, waved him away, and left angrily for the Democratic side of the aisle.

    Cruz said the day after the fight that Gaiser was the only option for the seat, and that if the Judiciary Committee did not move him forward the people of Texas would pay the price because Democrats would keep the seat vacant in perpetuity, which he called a tragedy.

    Cornyn said Gaiser is not from Texas, has not been vetted, and that there are better qualified people to hold the lifetime job.

  7. On the Senate floor, Cornyn berated Senator Ted Cruz over the nomination, shouting that he did not find him credible and that he was mad at him, loudly enough to be heard in the press gallery.

    Cornyn also shouted on the floor about someone ending his career, and reporters could not tell whether he meant Cruz or Trump.

    Cornyn questioned the nomination, saying, "I don't know why a Texas senator would agree to a nomination of somebody from Ohio for one of the most important district benches in the state, in Dallas."

    Cruz refused to discuss the confrontation, saying only, "You'd have to ask him."

    Cornyn said Cruz was unhappy because the White House had made it impossible for him to back Gaiser.

  8. T. Elliot Gaiser, expected to appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, was not among the seven judicial nominees who testified, derailing the nomination.

    Cornyn said Gaiser's nomination was no longer viable, that the Constitution provides for advice and consent but there was no consultation on the nomination, and that the Senate is not supposed to be a rubber stamp and has been one too often.

  9. Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts attacked Senator John Cornyn on X for blocking the nomination and mocked the end of his Senate career, and the two traded sharp statements.

    In a post on X, Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts wrote, "John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico's agenda started early. What a legacy."

    Cornyn replied, "Kevin, your sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution, and in so doing you have made yourself irrelevant."

    Roberts answered that he was "genuinely sorry to see you tarnish your legacy and years of service with this petulance," and said Heritage would still be fighting for the everyday American, not K Street.

    Roberts also wrote that Gaiser is "one of the most brilliant legal minds of this generation" and warned that Cornyn's pettiness would give the seat to a radical leftist judge.

  10. A White House official said the administration expects all of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year.

    A White House official said the administration expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by year's end, and did not say whether it would swap in Cornyn's alternative candidate.

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.