John Cornyn and Ted Cruz clash on Senate floor over blocked Gaiser nomination

RUKUS· · 2d ← 5d
Go Rogue

Donald Trump nominated T. Elliot Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, to a federal judgeship in northern Texas in November 2026.

Outgoing Senator John Cornyn of Texas blocked the nomination by withholding his blue slip, saying Gaiser is not from Texas and was never vetted.

Gaiser was pulled from the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, and Cornyn instead recommends former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey for the seat.

Democrats take control of the Senate on January 3, leaving Republicans little time to confirm Trump's remaining judicial nominees.

The block drew criticism from the Justice Department, Ted Cruz, and conservative influencers, and Cornyn traded barbs with Cruz and Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts.

  1. Cornyn said he was blocking Gaiser's nomination, refusing to return the blue slip home-state senators typically must give for a judicial nominee to advance.

    Cornyn told CNN he refused to be jammed by a non-Texan with no trial experience who had not been vetted.

  2. Cornyn pushed the White House to replace Gaiser days before the hearing and recommended former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey for the Northern District of Texas seat.

    Cornyn said the White House bypassed the bipartisan screening committee Texas senators use to vet judicial candidates, and raised concerns about Gaiser's work on Trump's 2020 election challenges.

    Donald Trump nominated Gaiser, who heads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, to the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas.

    Cornyn told the Associated Press, 'Trying to air-drop somebody else in at the last minute for the Dallas vacancy that hasn't been through that process, I think, is a concern.'

    Conservative actor Matthew Marsden called Cornyn's move 'a disgrace'.

    Eric Daugherty wrote 'Let him through!' on X, urging Cornyn to 'Do the right thing for America!'

    Ryan Fournier wrote that Cornyn was blocking Trump's judicial nominee Elliot Gaiser by withholding his blue slip, calling the lifetime judgeship a GOP standoff.

    Jeremy Carl of the Claremont Institute wrote, 'Gaiser is one of the best possible GOP judicial picks. So it makes sense that Cornyn would oppose him.'

    Mila Joy wrote, 'Lame duck Cornyn strikes again', adding, 'His wittle feelings are still hurt.'

  3. T. Elliot Gaiser was abruptly removed from the Senate Judiciary Committee's Wednesday hearing schedule after Cornyn declined to return his blue slip.

    The Senate Judiciary Committee received Gaiser's nomination paperwork on November 8, 2026, and reportedly had no part in choosing him, unlike Trump's other Texas judicial picks.

  4. Gaiser's Senate questionnaire showed Cruz's staff first contacted him about the judgeship on November 4, 2026, the day after the election.

  5. A Justice Department spokesperson described Cornyn's decision as 'disappointing'.

    A Justice Department spokesperson called Gaiser 'a brilliant legal mind, a principled defender of the Constitution, and an outstanding judicial nominee'.

    Cornyn said 'the Senate's not supposed to be a rubber stamp' and that it should exercise independent scrutiny rather than automatically approve White House selections.

    Cornyn said in a statement that Gaiser was 'airdropped into the process without any consultation with the senators'.

  6. Gaiser did not appear at the Wednesday Judiciary Committee hearing on the last batch of Trump's judicial nominees.

  7. Cornyn said there was zero consultation with him on Gaiser's nomination and that he did not know whether it would be formally withdrawn.

    Gaiser had already been through the background check process because he was confirmed for his current Justice Department position.

    Cornyn said he would block the nomination and would not return the blue slip, saying Gaiser is not from Texas and has not been vetted for the lifetime judgeship.

    The Justice Department said it is 'deeply disappointing that Senator Cornyn would choose political obstruction over advancing a highly qualified nominee'.

    Ted Cruz warned that if the Senate Judiciary Committee did not move Gaiser forward, 'the people of Texas will pay the price' because the seat would effectively go to Democrats, who would keep it vacant in perpetuity.

    Cruz said the White House had been explicit that there was no time to complete a background check for another potential nominee.

    A White House official said the administration expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of 2026.

  8. Cornyn replied, 'Kevin, your sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution, and in so doing you have made yourself irrelevant.'

    Roberts replied that when Cornyn returned to Texas out of office, Heritage and its affiliates 'will still be fighting for the everyday American, not K Street'.

    Roberts wrote, 'I am genuinely sorry to see you tarnish your legacy and years of service with this petulance.'

    Roberts called Gaiser one of the most brilliant legal minds of this generation and warned that Cornyn's pettiness would give the judgeship seat to a radical leftist judge.

  9. Cornyn and Cruz argued loudly on the Senate floor over Gaiser's nomination, with the press gallery hearing Cornyn say, 'I don't find you credible. I'm mad at you.'

    During the argument Cornyn said he was upset at someone 'for ending my career', without making clear whether he meant Trump or Cruz.

    Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts wrote on X, 'John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico's agenda started early. What a legacy.'

Sign in with subscription

Free during the beta.

Clear all notifications?

Your bells stay on. Only this list empties.