Cornyn calls Cruz fragile as feud over Trump judicial nominee escalates
John Cornyn mocks Ted Cruz as 'fragile' amid Trump feud
Trump says Cornyn blocked judicial pick because his ‘feelings were hurt’
GOP senator taunts Trump after tanking president's nominee: 'Why did he wait?'
Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
GOP senator berates Ted Cruz on the Senate floor as feud boils over: 'I'm mad at you!'
“That’s Bullsh*t”: John Cornyn and Ted Cruz Get Into Shouting Match
Elliot Gaiser has few ties to Texas. But he has plenty of praise for Ted Cruz.
President Donald Trump picked T. Elliot Gaiser, who has few professional ties to Texas, for a lifetime seat on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Gaiser had a record of political support for Senator Ted Cruz dating to prepared remarks from February 1, 2016, and his Senate questionnaire showed Cruz's office contacted him on November 4, 2026, the day after midterms that gave Democrats control of the Senate. He spoke with staff from Senator John Cornyn's office two days later, and he did not go through Texas's customary screening process for federal judicial candidates.
The dispute turned public on November 18, when Cornyn and Cruz got into a shouting match on the mostly empty Senate floor and Cornyn stormed away toward the Democratic side of the aisle. Cornyn called Cruz fragile and said he had not returned the blue slip for Gaiser, a Dallas-area nomination made earlier in the month, a refusal that effectively vetoes it, and said there was zero consultation with him. Cruz said the White House had been explicit there was no time to complete a background check for another nominee, noting Gaiser had already been checked through his confirmation to his current Justice Department position. A White House official said the administration expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of 2026, while Cornyn said he did not know whether Gaiser's nomination would be formally withdrawn.
By November 21 the fight had an alternative: Cornyn's preferred candidate is Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor in the Northern District of Texas now a partner at Kirkland & Ellis, and Cornyn said the White House had requested information about him.
President Donald Trump selected T. Elliot Gaiser, who has few professional ties to Texas, for a lifetime appointment as a federal judge on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas.
Gaiser's Senate questionnaire showed staff from Senator Ted Cruz's office contacted him on November 4, 2026, the day after midterm elections in which Democrats won control of the Senate.
The questionnaire showed Gaiser spoke with staff from Senator John Cornyn's office on November 6, 2026, and learned from the White House that he was under consideration for the vacancy.
Gaiser's questionnaire disclosed prepared remarks from February 1, 2016, documenting a history of political support for Ted Cruz that preceded the call from Cruz's office.
Gaiser did not go through Texas's customary judicial screening process for federal judicial candidates.
Cornyn said he and Cruz had previously recommended other candidates who had undergone the Texas screening process, and he publicly questioned whether Gaiser should receive the appointment.
Cornyn criticized the White House for bypassing the Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee that Texas senators traditionally use to vet judicial candidates, saying trying to 'air-drop' someone else into the Dallas vacancy at the last minute without that process is a concern.
Gaiser was expected to appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee for his confirmation hearing on November 18, 2026.
Senators John Cornyn and Ted Cruz got into a shouting match on the mostly empty Senate floor over Gaiser's nomination, and Cornyn stormed away toward the Democratic side of the aisle.
Cornyn was refusing to return the blue slip for Gaiser, who had been nominated for a Dallas-area federal judgeship earlier in the month, a refusal that effectively vetoes the nomination.
Cornyn shouted at Cruz, 'I don't find you credible. I'm mad at you!', loud enough to be heard in the press gallery.
Cornyn told Cruz, 'Oh, that's bullshit' before storming away.
Cornyn said Gaiser is not from Texas, has not been vetted, and that there are better qualified people to hold the lifetime job.
Cornyn said of Cruz, 'I don't know why a Texas senator would agree to a nomination of somebody from Ohio for one of the most important district benches in the state, in Dallas.'
Cruz said Gaiser was the only option for the seat and warned that if the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move him forward, the people of Texas will pay the price because Democrats will keep the seat vacant in perpetuity, which he called a tragedy.
Cornyn said he was upset at someone 'for ending my career', and reporters could not tell whether he meant Cruz or Trump.
Cornyn said Cruz was unhappy because the White House had made it impossible for him to back Gaiser.
Cruz refused to discuss the clash, saying only, 'You'd have to ask him.'
Cornyn said he had not returned his blue slip for Gaiser and did not plan to.
Cornyn said there was zero consultation with him on Gaiser's nomination.
Cornyn said he did not know whether Gaiser's nomination would be formally withdrawn.
A White House official said the administration expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of 2026.
Cruz said the White House had been explicit that there was no time to complete a background check for another potential nominee.
Gaiser had already been through the background check process through his confirmation to his current Justice Department position.
Cornyn said he would block Gaiser's nomination, one of Trump's final judicial picks.
Cornyn called Gaiser 'a very bright young man with a very bright future' and said he feels Gaiser has been used as a pawn in the process.
The Justice Department said Cornyn's 'political antics only hurt the American public and the rule of law'.
The Justice Department called Gaiser 'a brilliant legal mind,' a principled defender of the Constitution, and an outstanding nominee, and said it is deeply disappointing that Cornyn chose political obstruction over advancing a highly qualified nominee.
Cruz said Gaiser is the only nominee who could actually be confirmed by the end of 2026.
Cornyn's preferred candidate for the Dallas vacancy is Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor in the Northern District of Texas who later became a partner at Kirkland & Ellis.
In a post on X on November 21, Cornyn asked why Trump waited until after the midterm elections to nominate someone for the Dallas seat, which has been vacant since 2025.
In the post, Cornyn said Trump nominated, without consultation, a non-Texan with little connection to Texas, no trial court experience, and no appropriate vetting for a lifetime job, making the Senate's constitutional duty of 'advise and consent' impossible.
Cornyn wrote that he would like to work with Trump to fill the seat while Republicans still hold the Senate majority, and that he had forwarded an outstanding candidate highly rated by the bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee and interviewed by White House Counsel, needing only an FBI background check.
Cornyn wrote, 'Back to you, Mr. President. Time is of the essence.'
Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts accused Cornyn of handing the seat to a 'Radical Leftist judge.'
In a television interview, Trump said Cornyn blocked Gaiser because his 'feelings were hurt,' saying Cornyn 'was beaten in the primary, and he feels badly about it.'
Trump said Cornyn would have lost reelection in November 'by a lot' had he not lost the Republican primary.
Cornyn said the White House had requested information about his alternative nominee, Steve Fahey.
In a post on X, Cornyn wrote, 'Everyone knows that I am a notorious cusser and screamer and that Ted is a fragile thing. But enough about us.'
In a television interview, Cruz confirmed the exchange, saying, 'Only one of us was shouting. I was not shouting, but it is true that John Cornyn was shouting at me and cursing at me on the Senate floor, and that's what the reporters in the gallery reported on.'
Cruz linked the outburst to Cornyn's primary defeat, saying, 'Losing an election is hard, and people get upset about it. I understand that. I understand that frustration. I have won elections. I've lost elections. There's no doubt winning is a lot more fun.'
Cruz said that when he asked Cornyn why he would 'give this seat to the Democrats,' Cornyn said no, got very angry, 'began screaming,' and 'began cursing at me.'
In a television appearance, Trump said of Gaiser, 'Everybody tells me he's outstanding and he's being held up by John Cornyn because John Cornyn's feelings were hurt,' calling Cornyn a nice guy who is 'doing a tremendous disservice because Gaiser is fantastic.'
In a post on X directed at Cruz, Cornyn wrote that if a president can appoint someone from another state, no senator will have a say in their state notwithstanding Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the Constitution, which 'is called "advise and consent."'
